
Sponsored by


![]()

![]()
September 2005
September is upon us again with the familiar warm evenings and wonderful sunsets after our seasonable afternoon thunderstorms. Snook season has opened and the hunt is on for the linesiders. There are still plenty of fish on the beaches and creek mouths of Florida Bay. I have been up in the bites, you know Garfield, Rankin and that whole shoreline all the way to the dragover with lots of luck. Young tarpon in the five-pound class rolling about, snook taking top water Skitter Walks, redfish tailing in the very skinny waters, it is the time to pole. The winds are minimal this time of year making it a time to just pole along slowly in six to eight inches of water looking for pushes and waking fish.
Here is the Captain with a nice little 10-pound bonefish
Reviving the fish with a Gripper Tool before the release.
Lets talk real skinny water for a minute. Whether you are in Biscayne Bay or Florida Bay some of the very best times I have had guiding a client is in six to eight inches of water. Biscayne Bay and it’s bonefish tailing on the last of an outgoing tide trying to get the last feed on before Cutter Bank goes dry is what’s its all about for me. Pushing my Maverick along leaving a vee pattern in the grass flats trying to get close enough to make a cast at a twelve pounder that is just tailing like there is no tomorrow, this is the very essence of flats fishing. To be on the outside of Caesar’s Creek at a dead low just as the tide starts to flow in over the south side flats, the permit will be just on the edges of the cut. They will work up and down those edges, then as the water level rises to the point of they’re being just enough water, they will tail on the shallow flat as they feed. The tails will look like black fillet knife blades as they stick out of the water darting along.
Here is the proof that a snook can eat a mullet ten inches long…. Just look at the Gripper Tool in my hand. This is only a 31-inch fish.
Pushing over the hump on Snake bite flat as the tide floods the flat, the grass is slowly disappearing, and as the first wave of mullet start mudding is when the first redfish and snook will slowly follow them. You have seen the bait being flushed out of the water as the sharks tear into the mullet...well it isn’t always a shark doing that. There will be plenty of snook, redfish and of course large seatrout in the mix as well. But you need the shallow draft and silence of a top quality hull to get close enough.
Some of the hulls that can do this with ease are of course the Maverick HPX-V (my ride) and HPX-Tunnel hulls and most of the Hell’s Bay series of skiffs. Many people use an aluminum hull for this kind of fishing but I have found these hulls to be very noisy as well as providing a horrendous ride in a chop. But then again some of the aforementioned tunnels ride very ruff in a chop but the advantage is they are silent and draft only a few inches when it is most needed, when "sight fishing".
Got a chance to take my wife Julie the Marine Artist out fishing. The winds were non-existent but the dorado were everywhere!!!!!
The shallow water and stillness of this water even in a fifteen to twenty knot wind makes approaching a game fish very difficult. Part of the key is to approach very slowly with very little movement from you as the guide poling and from your angler. This type of "sight fishing" requires very short accurate casting and buckets of patience but the dividends are priceless. One trick to having the visibility of the guy on the tower is to have a front casting platform, or you can take your cooler and stand on it on the bow. This will elevate you sixteen to eighteen inches and you will not believe the difference. Just remember the fish can see you better as well. Keep your movements down to a minimum, when you see a fish go a crouching position to make your cast, and cast from the side rather than overhead. Just the movement of your rod can spook fish in eight inches of clear water.
Well good luck with the snook and I’ll see you "On the Flats".
Gear Check
I have been using the new 8, 10 & 15-pound Power-Pro Lines now for almost three years and I am here to say…I am a believer. The 8-pound is just like thread (has a dia. of one-pound test monofilament) and throws a 2/0 circle hook with a medium size shrimp a country mile. The long casts mean the less chance of spooking bonefish and permit while on the flats. The 15-pound test is a great tool for getting those snook out of a mangrove shoreline. The 15-pound has a dia. of four-pound test monofilament and can spool almost 300 yards on a Quantum Cabo 40 reel. This is a great advantage for tarpon fishing and for all of the offshore species.
August 2005
Summer is almost gone with the dog days of August here. The fishing has been very good this season in Biscayne Bay. Permit have been overrunning the flats inside and outside of the bay with some very large fish being caught. Targeting permit on spin is a real treat; I start off at the bait shop. Rather than getting five-dozen shrimp and a couple of crabs like I do most of the rest of the year, I order two-dozen crabs and a dozen shrimp. The first dozen of crabs should be the size of a quarter for the large bones and smaller permit, and the second dozen should be the size of a silver dollar. The larger crabs will give you longer casts for the tailing fish and the fish over fifteen pounds will eat them up like M&M’s
Well August is here again, and again we look forward to September first for the snook season to open. The flats are loaded with this fiery villain sitting poised to strike at a properly presented bait. One of my favorites is the High Roller/Rip Roller in the 3.25" size and in the colors of either Florida Special or the new Green Back. Other top water baits like the new Rapala Skitter Walk in the mullet pattern has worked very well. Capt. Rick Murphy gave me a couple of these baits after the ICAST Show to see what I thought, and I like them.
Rapala’ s Skitter Walk
Don’t forget the plastics. My Spike-It Holographic Jerk Baits have been doing the trick in this warm water as well. Rigged Texas Style using a 1/16th oz. bullet weight for casting distance really helps, it also allows the head of the bait to fall naturally. This has been the formula for success catching at least two or three snook before the heat of the day slows down the bite and makes the fish hide out in the deeper edges or cuts of Flamingo. Remember that the snook is a nocturnal feeder so the best time will be at dawn and dusk for the biggest fish.
Spike-It Holographic 5" Jerkbait in Black/Clear
The early part of the day has been the best for the bonefishing. Being on the water at sunrise is a necessity due to the cooler water temperatures. This is the toughest time for me to tag a bonefish with this hot water. I have been on the University of Miami Bonefish Research program for almost four years now and have gotten a lot of information from the research they are performing. A single bonefish over his lifespan is valued at $70,000.00 to the economy here in South Florida, this is just amazing to me. If you have fished with me you will notice I don’t tag all of the fish we catch, as is my standard practice. I will only tag a bone that has been landed in the best of shape to lessen the impact on the fish and ensure it’s survival. I will take a lot of time reviving every fish caught to ensure the fish has had a chance to recover from the fight before releasing him. I hope you all practice the same care when releasing one of our precocious bonefish.
The Mahi Mahi are at their best during the month of August and with my new Panga 28 & Evinrude E-Tec combination I am having a ball out there. Call for reservations to fish this amazing hull and see for yourself how this boat performs.
Gear Check
I have been fishing offshore with the arrival of my new "TOY" the Panga 28, and have the chance to use a few new baits. One of them is a new processed bait called Tuff-E-Nuff. This is a squid wing processed tough as leather and developed to stay on your hook longer. I use a long strip to drag on my feathers and if hooked right it will not spin at all. I will use smaller strips to tip a jig and even smaller strips to catch bait. Being processed it doesn’t STINK like un-processed squid and is very strong, and "Boy-O-Boy" does it catch dolphin. Check it out at http://anglerschoicebaitcompany.com/
Or give the boy’s at Anglers Choice a call at (877) 283-1670. Come out for a trip and I will show you what I mean.
July 2005
July is here and the word is the tarpon are HOT, HOT, HOT. The water temperatures were a little late this year and so are the tarpon and there normal monthly movements. When we talk about tarpon the target months are May & June, but this year there is a lot of talk that there is a lag in the cycle of about three weeks. Tarpon don’t go by the calendar, their cycle is dictated by the water temperatures and wind directions. So look at the runs to be a little bit late this year.
Look for a good push of fish along the outside of the Keys up to Miami all heading north and a real good concentration of fish out on the Flamingo beaches.
With my new Panga 28 from Panga.com Fishing Boats, I am in blue water heaven. The fuel efficiency is just amazing. Leaving Homestead Bayfront Park and running out 20 miles to run & gun for six to seven hours has only resulted in a fuel bill of $55 to $70. The Evinrude E-Tec 200 has performed flawlessly with a top speed of 46 MPH. Not bad for a 28’ boat and a single 200 HP engine with 4 passengers aboard.

Here are a couple of shots of some nice Mahi-Mahi we have been finding every time out.
Heidi and Nancy from Ft. Lauderdale joined old friend Mike for a great day offshore.
I have been finding the bite to be between 400 & 700 feet through the end of June depending on the wind direction and speed. Always looking for a well-defined weed line with the other eye on the horizon looking for birds diving the dolphin have been very cooperative. Call now to reserve a trip this summer to check out this remarkable hull and engine combination or just to catch a bunch of dolphin, mangrove snapper, grouper and muttons aboard the Quantum Leap!

There has been a great bite of Mangrove snapper and muttons this year as well.
The full moon in June is the spawn for many bottom fish like the mangrove snapper and mutton snapper. Here is my wife Julie with a nice mutton last year on the Panga 22.
As for the bonefishing, with July here we will see the water temperatures rising still to the point of driving the bonefish off the flats during the middle of the day, although the permit will be showing more and more as the waters heat up. Target your bonefishing on those days of an early morning, incoming tides. The influx of cooler water flooding the flats will turn on the bite and give you a better chance of hooking the grey ghost of the flats.

Leo & George came out from California to
Experience out inshore fishing and we had a great time
With eight new species added to their list.
This is the best time to try for the Grand Slam of the flats. To catch a bone, permit and tarpon in the same day is very possible during the three months of summer. Permit being the toughest of the three to get to eat, this is the time of year the greatest numbers of fish gather on our flats. Target them with a quarter to half dollar size crab on a 2/0 circle hook and 20 pound fluorocarbon leader and hold on for the fight of your life. Have your boat captain keep fairly close to help keep the line out of the fan coral and off the bottom for your best chances to keep a fish all the way to a photo finish.
Gear Check
I have been fishing offshore with the arrival of my new "TOY" the Panga 28, and have the chance to use a few new baits. One of them is the Fishskin Flyers by ProFish Co. I like two colors, all clear/white and the green-orange-yellow combination This is an ultra light trolling bait that stays almost weedless with a single hook and "Boy-O-Boy" does it catch dolphin. Check it out at http://profishco.com/fishskinflyer.asp Come out for a trip and I will show you what I mean.
The other bait I have been using is the Feather Bullet Dorado by Chaos. The feathers have fantastic action and the color combination is the best. Check this bait out specifically at http://www.chaosfishing.com/species.asp?parent_id=1&species_id=22&lure_id=56
June 2005
June is the best time to slam on the flats. The Tarpon are all over the inside and outside flats, Permit are here in great numbers and the bonefish are starting to school in their summer patterns. Now is the best time to go for the big three and receive the coveted award from the IGFA. All you have to do is record your catches on film and have the paperwork from IGFA to apply for the certificate that is a beautiful addition to anyone’s trophy wall.
I like this size Tarpon.. They are very spastic upon the hook set and you don’t need a bag lunch and a flashlight to land them.
I want to talk a minute about light lining for big fish. This seams to be the craze of late to catch a huge fish on the lightest line possible, well this has its drawbacks. I have caught tarpon on a Quantum seven-foot rod made for 8-15 pound test and a Quantum Cabo 40 with 10-pound test Power-Pro and the fight that followed lasted up to two hours. This is a tremendous strain on the fish. Without taking the fish out of the water for a photo, it still took a half hour to revive the fish enough to have a safe release. From know on I will only target large tarpon with a minimum of 15 pound test. I think this is best for the fish as well as the angler. I think it is a win-win situation going to a heavier line. The fish has a better chance for survival, the angler has more control of the fish during the fight, and the line doesn’t end up with as much twist after the fight.
June fishing should be exactly what we had hoped for in the sense of wind direction, speed and temperatures. The afternoon build-up of thunder storms dictate we start our days early and end them around 2 pm. This is a good practice also due to the South Florida sun baking our anglers to a crisp in the afternoon. Keep in mind you must reapply a generous amount of sunscreen every three hours and keep the flow of liquids into yourself as well as your anglers to keep from becoming toast as we head into the summer months. Reminding my anglers of both of these necessities I feel is a very important part of being a good guide.
With the winds of May hopefully behind us we look forward to those quiet, sun filled morning’s on our flats here in Biscayne Bay, bonefish up & tailing on the low-incoming tides, permit in schools on the outside creek points looking for crabs and tarpon daisy chaining down the coastal flats. There are a lot of smaller resident tarpon throughout the creeks and channels of our bay as well, just waiting for a well placed shrimp from one of my anglers to shoot skyward and show his stuff.
For those of you who watched me build this boat, here’s you chance to own her.
FOR-SALE $6000.00 w/ NEW Johnson 15HP Two Stroke
Call me for details 305-248-6126
Gear Check
Even with the wind being up we have been able to fly fish with the help of the Pro Trim Line Tamer. This stripping bucket takes away almost all of the aggravation when trying to cast in a wind and is a much-needed tool on my bow when there is a 15 or 20-knot wind blowing. We have been using the Nautilus fly reels with Thomas & Thomas Horizon Graphite Fly Rods with much the delight of my anglers. These reels are of the highest quality you can find out there on the market period. If you feel that you need to spend more money on a reel ….Buy Two.
May 2005
With a good wind comes a little security for the flats inhabitants. The bones and permit tend to really eat well during a 20-knot wind. True, it is a little harder to see them, but on the other hand it is also harder for them to see us. The wind also covers the splash down of your offering much better. If you have ever tried to land a shrimp near a tailing bonefish in flat calm water, you know what I mean. Most of the time you get the reaction that you have hit him in the head with a baseball or a Volkswagen!!! So if it’s blowing, don’t hesitate to go fishing, you will be happy you did.
Look for the permit to be in the two to three foot ranges along the bonefish flats as they follow mudding rays. This is one of the easiest ways of spotting fish and a great chance to approach those fish when they have their attention focused on something other than your approach. Work an edge looking shallow for bones as well as deep for the chance of a shot at a permit and you will be pleasantly surprised.
Brian w/ a 13-3/4 lbs. FAT BOY!!!!! Chris w/ a 25-lbs. Black-eyed P
I have been fishing Chris and his 16-year-old son, Brian Dolne for four years now and this year has been another good one for Brian. Coming down for the spring break Brian makes the most of his two trips a year once again landing a 13-¾ pound bonefish this trip. A remarkable angler for his age, his total for the week was an added 11-1/2 pounder and a 9 pound bone, and let’s not forget the Tarpon, Sharks and 40+ Barracuda. Fishing the south end of Biscayne Bay during the 20 to 30 knot winds, Chris did well too with a 25-pound Permit, an 8-1/2 pound bone, sharks and 50+ Barracuda’s. Hailing from Indiana these guys’s like to Pike and Musky fish, so there interest in the Cuda is shown by their catch records.
There is no better time to be a fisherman or guide here in South Florida than the months of April, May & June. I sometimes find it to be the hardest at these times, when there are boats all over the place, to keep the right distance from other anglers. Other boats are cutting off my fish when I am on a tarpon run or a bonefish flat, people are running all over the flats trying to get from one spot to another. This is when we need to discipline ourselves the most.
When you are out there fishing, please try to remember not to run over flats that someone might want to fish, even if there isn’t anyone in sight. Keep your distance from other boats that are in line on a tarpon run. When approaching another boat, try to think of how he or she is fishing, are they drifting a flat? Are they poling down wind and away from the sun for the best visibility? Or they set up on a point waiting for a school of tarpon to cross their path. In any of these scenarios, give way to allow plenty of room. If you can see who it is in the boat, or if it is a Maverick or a Hell’s Bay, YOU’RE TOO CLOSE.
THE

AMERICAN VETERANS FISH-OFF
July 1st, 2005
Were back …..and again this year, I will be looking for Licensed Captains to volunteer a half-day morning to take our American Veterans fishing. This year we will be filming the event with a full production company and producing a nice DVD for all involved. Great fun and a whole bunch of flag waving saying thanks to our American Veterans who have served to protect the freedom we all enjoy. If you are a Captain and want to participate or know a disabled veteran who likes to fish please contact me to get their name on the captain/angler list.
We are also looking for any contributions to help fund the event. Last year we had free lunch, drinks, tee shirts and boat bags for the vet’s and some nice trophies from Julie Sutton Marine Art and Mike Stasko of Fine Art Printmaking for the best fish stories of the day, so please help to make this "a day to remember" for our veterans.
Contact: Capt. Dave Sutton
305-248-6126 offices
786-564-6347 cell
www.saltwater-flyfisherman.com
djsutton@bellsouth.net
Gear Check
Now is the time to get out your 11 & 12 weight Thomas & Thomas fly rods to prepare for the Tarpon runs of spring. You can loosen up in Whitewater Bay blind casting for the kings to get yourself into the rhythm of throwing the heavy rods again. Clean your reels and lines then check your backing and don’t forget to throw out any old rusty hooked tarpon flies. See Franco at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop for the latest patterns and "lets get it on"!!!!
April 2005
April is coming and May soon to follow. This is the best time to be a Captain here in South Florida. The Tarpon will soon be off Biscayne Bay, (they are already on the outside of Flamingo) the bones are warming up on the flats, the permit have already shown up on our flats and the list goes on & on.
Yes it’s true, I am know going "OFF THE DEEP END" My new Panga 28 is here and I am just totally in heaven. The pic above is the 26 footer but the 28 is the same hull design lengthened by two feet. I have a Key West style T-top, a 35-gallon live well leaning post and the best engine on the block to push her. My new 225 E-Tec by Evinrude is just amazing. Jack at Sea Power Inc. did the deed and hooked me up with an awesome engine. How about THREE MILES a gallon from a TWO-STROKE!!!!! All the power and performance of a two stroke with the fuel efficiency of a four-stroke engine was just a dream.Camp-Out Inc. & Continental Trailers hooked me up with a totally tricked out aluminum trailer to get her to the water and Image Graphics will be doing a full wrap to include Quantum, Eagle Claw, Evinrude and Fish Hedz to name only a few. I will be doing Gulf wrecks for cobia, grouper, snapper and many more as well as testing the dolphin, sailfish, and the rest of the Atlantic species on some brand new Quantum Gear. Call to book a trip on this new Panga hull and see for yourself why this hull design has been around for over thirty years.
The winds have finally calmed down and the bite should drastically improve in the bay. The bonefish have been very present all over the southern bay in large schools, all the way down the Upper Keys. I have seen schools in the twenties out on the inside of the Ragged Keys south down to Garden Cove flats. Inside of Rabbit key Basin has gotten much better as of late as well, with reports of large schools moving on the strong tides. Look for tailers on the incoming tides on the outside of Elliot all along the deep edges waiting for the water to rise up onto the flats, but keep an eye out for permit in the 2 to 3 foot water as the tide rises. Look for this to just get better as the water warms.
Tarpon have been reported moving north along the outside of Key Largo and the shore up to Sands Cut in good numbers and have been eaters on chartreuse early in the day and tans to olive patterns midday. There have been good numbers of tarpon moving on the outer edges of First National Bank south & east all the way down to Springer Bank. Look for rollers and get in front of them and take a shot. The patterns are a closely kept secret between the guides and to ask them for the color is my only hope. The colors I have had luck on are the same as listed above in the Bay, just add a yellow and white in the mix for the midday bite. This will also improve, as the water gets warmer.
There is still a ban on taking the Goliath Grouper in Florida waters, but I have been catching far too many of them to feel a need for a zero bag limit. The same story is true of the gulf fishery. Fishing the sand holes, potholes and wreaks of the gulf I have experienced the abundant numbers of Goliath’s. While snapper and cobia fishing we have found that a Goliath has moved in to the wreak and will not allow us to boat more than four to five fish without making our snappers live-bait. Once the grouper has moved out of his hole, you cannot bring up another fish without him jumping all over it. I think we should have a minimum size and a daily bag limit of at least one of these fish to help ease the pressure a 200-pound fish like this can make on a small fishing spot
March 2005
With the cold fronts finally over, now all we have to put up with is this winds of March. It seems they have started early this year and will hopefully end early. Water temperatures are reaching the tolerable levels of 68 degrees in the morning and a late afternoon rise to 72degrees on our waters of Flamingo and Biscayne Bay, making the start of spring pleasantly approaching.
Winter Tarpon is still ok from the bridges of Miami all the way over to Florida Bay and Flamingo. Whitewater Bay has been a frequent haunt for my anglers while throwing HighRollers and Bagley’s mullet baits for the Kings. Landing one fish a day has been the average if we have the patience to throw, although you need to jump another three fish to keep the odds this good. Casting poppers and shallow divers is a lot of fun for these giants, especially when they take a swing at your lure five feet away from the boat. Remember, natural colors in clean water and bright colors in dirty water has been the measure of success on my boat this season.
Throwing a fly has only been done by the die-hard anglers who can stand up to blind casting in a fifteen-knot wind for a chance of jumping a fish up to 170 pounds. As tuff as it may sound, this has been the tactics that has landed eight fish over a hundred pounds in the last month. Snook and redfish are all over the backcountry of Flamingo as well as the outside flats into Florida Bay. Cobia and tripletail are on the crab pot buoys and the Spanish macks are also in full force.
I have been testing bay boats over the last year and have come to only one inevitable conclusion, I need a BIGGER BOAT for what I want to do. I have a yen to fish the deep gulf wrecks and have had many requests for the angling adventure that exists out there. Well, I think I have found the boat to do the Job.
After much to do I have settled on a 28 foot Panga By Panga Fishing Boats of Miami. Panga.com is their web site and you can see the "ORIGINAL" Panga hull design there. Watch the videos they have and check out the gallery of boats from Mexico to Japan. If you have any further questions just give me a call or you can call Art de la Nuez at Panga Fishing Boats. His number is 305-971-7485.
I kept coming back to this hull for it’s simple forty-year old hull design that rides a heavy chop like a deep-V, runs very efficient like a modified-V, and floats in shallow water like a flats boat. The hull gives an uncommonly dry ride in an unruly sea and has the uncanny ability to run very fast top end speeds with a single outboard. "No boat has ALL of these abilities," you say, well I will prove it to you as soon as I get my new Panga hopefully by the end of March.
Fishing enthusiasts can take advantage of early-bird registration for the
2005 Herman Lucerne Memorial Backcountry Fishing Competition and save $25 on the
entry fee. Presented by Hell's Bay Boatworks and Mercury, the sixth annual
catch-and-release event takes place April 15-17 in the waters of the Florida Bay
and Everglades National Park. It will benefit services at the new Homestead
Hospital that is under
construction just east of the Florida Turnpike off Campbell Drive and scheduled
to open in late 2006.
The charity backcountry fishing competition honors the memory of Herman
Lucerne, a devoted fisherman, community activist and former mayor of Florida
City who loved children. The competition's grand prize is an 18-foot Glades
skiff with a 25-horsepower Mercury outboard motor and a Hell's Bay trailer.
Trophies and a $300 cash prize will be awarded to the anglers and teams who
catch the largest fish in each of the eight eligible species, including snook,
tarpon, bonefish, redfish, trout, snapper, bass and black drum. There also is a
$1,000 cash prize to the top guide. The competition is an International Game
Fish Association (IGFA) sanctioned event.
"We are proud of the way this competition has grown," said Lloyd Wruble,
DMD, event chairperson. "Participants enjoy friendly competition in the
beautiful waters of Florida Bay, receive fabulous items in the boat bag made
possible by our sponsors, and know they are raising money that for a great
cause."
In addition to the presenting sponsors Hell's Bay Boatworks and Mercury,
more than one dozen companies have signed up to support the event including,
Acosta Farms, Community Bank of Florida, Dion Oil Company, Eagle Claw Hooks,
First National Bank of South Florida, Florida Hi-way Marine Insurance, Florida
Nurserymen Growers & Landscapers Association, Grove Services Inc., Hook &
Tackle, HOPS Restaurant, Karen Realty Group, Publix Super Markets Charities,
Stainless Marine, The Mead Family Charitable Foundation and Smith-Barney.
The entry fee for the Herman Lucerne Memorial Backcountry Fishing
Competition for IGFA members is $300 for each angler who registers before March
18; $325 each after March 18. Non-IGFA members must add $10 to the
entry fee for a one-year membership. Junior angler participation in the
competition is welcome. With the entry fee, each angler receives a bag of
boat-related items, one ticket to the kick-off
event with a fish-fry dinner on Friday, April 15 and one ticket to the
awards dinner on Sunday, April 17. Discounted accommodations at Flamingo
Marina and Outpost for that weekend are available to participants who
make reservations before March 15.
Entry forms and competition details are available at www.hermanlucerne.com, or
by calling the Homestead Hospital Foundation office at 786-243-8054. For
more information about the fishing competition, contact yours truly, Captain
Dave Sutton, Competition Director, at 305-248-6126. I’ll see you "On the Flats"
February 2005
Well the cold fronts have become a weekly tradition this past January and look like they might follow into February. It has been a mixed bag of windy days and cold fronts blowing through from the west and north making the bonefishing very tough. With the sudden drop of five degrees in water temperature the bones retreat to the deeper flats and forage there, rather than suffer the cold water on the shallower flats. It will take two or three days in succession to bring them back to tailing water. Watch the surface temps and get ready to fish. I have found that the magic number seems to be 68 degrees until the bonefish will begin to migrate onto the skinny water to feed.
February will show a few more of these cold fronts and with it the blustery winds of early spring to deal with as well. Try to work a specific flat for bonefish over and over again and you will see that there is a general set of conditions that will bring schools of fish to the flat. Wind direction, tide flow, time of tide, time of day and of course the position of the moon. All of these factors dictate whether you will see a few tailers or a few schools of tailers. But most importantly, be patient and enjoy the hunt, even if the score is lopsided. This is called fishing and even the very best guides will return to the dock at times with a final score of bonefish 8 & anglers nothing, every once and a while.
Snook season is open as of February 1st and here we go again. The winds of late winter/early spring are here as well. The flyfishing was still worth trying if you use a fly with weighted eyes and allowed it to fall to at least three feet before starting to strip. I like to use clousers and Borski’s Fur Shrimp for this due to the upward bent hook design of the fly and it’s sparse tie to help the sink rate. Colors we use are white and light tan, white and chartreuse and white and yellow. These colors seam to be the best bet for the deep edges of the channel and the snook love them.
On my fiftieth birthday, this past January 8th 2005 we buried my best friends son. He lost his life way too soon, and way too young. When faced with the decision to take a ride with someone who has been drinking, please say "NO" He was a son to Ron & Diane, a brother to Kera and Kelly and an uncle to Georgia & Savannah. He was a friend to many, a very good fisherman and he was only 21 years old. He earned a "Backcountry Grand Slam" in Flamingo on my boat in 2000. We laid him to rest with his favorite rod and a High Roller along with many other things from his friends and family.
"Peace Out" Butchie……
You will be missed "On the Flats"
January 2005
Welcome to 2005. I hope you all had a fantastic holiday even with the COLD fronts that came weekly this past December. Did someone move the Equator and neglected to let me know?
Well guess who won an EMMY!!!! The "Chevy’s Florida Fishing Reports" show airing on the Sunshine Network won a 2004 Sports Emmy this past December 11th. This is the first time a first year show has achieved such an award and the Sunshine Network is delighted.
My congratulations to Capt. Rick Murphy & Whit Watson, our Hosts of the show, Ken Kavanaugh, our Producer, Dave Ferrell, the "Off The Deep End Guy" and of course all of the "Magnificent Seven" Regional Experts that gave the weekly reports.
The "Magnificent Seven" are:
Northeast Regional Expert/Capt. Scott Guthrie,
Central East Regional Expert /Capt. Rodney Smith,
Southeast Regional Expert /Capt. Mike Holliday,
South Regional Expert /Capt. Dave Sutton,
Southwest Regional Expert /Capt. Ron Hueston,
Central West Regional Expert /Capt. Geoffrey Page,
Panhandle Regional Expert /Capt. Pat Dineen.
Hey Sunshine.. I have a place on my mantle all ready for my EMMY !!!!!!!!
As the cold fronts continue with the winds coming from all directions, even sometimes in the same day, I find myself waiting for the right times to take my anglers out to fish. Of course some are here on vacation and are restricted as to when they can go, but my local anglers are on stand-by for some of the best fishing they have ever seen. Watch the weather patterns develop, and you will see a cold front diminish to a two or three day warming trend until the next front will approach. These are the golden days for the flats fisherman. The warming days just before a new cold front moves in will be the most active days for the fish. As the barometer drops the bite will be on, all you have to do is be there.
January will show a few more of these cold fronts and with it the blustery winds of early spring to deal with as well. Try to work a specific flat for bonefish over and over again and you will see that there is a general set of conditions that will bring schools of fish to the flat. Wind direction, tide flow, tide time of day and of course the position of the moon. All of these factors dictate whether you will see a few tailers or a few schools of tailers. But most importantly, be patient and enjoy the hunt, even if the score is lopsided. This is called fishing and even the very best guides will return to the dock at times with a final score of bonefish 8 & anglers nothing.
The flyfishing is still worth trying if you use a fly with weighted eyes and allowed it to fall to at least three feet before starting to strip. I like to use clousers and Borski’s Fur Shrimp for this due to the upward bent hook design of the fly and it’s sparse tie to help the sink rate. Colors we use are white and light tan, white and chartreuse and white and yellow. These colors seam
There have been lots of fish on the outside wrecks as well. Making the trip out ten to fifteen miles from the Shark River or Sandy Key has been a gamble. The choice must be made on the right day to make the trip or the ride back can be very uncomfortable even in a twenty plus foot hull, but the trip is worth it. Large Snapper, Grouper, Black Drum, Tripletail, Cobia and a host of other species await you. Just use your best judgment and of course, the weather reports, and you will have plenty of work to do at the cleaning table upon your return.
Most of my fishing has been in the backcountry of Flamingo this past December. The weather has brought most of the anglers and guides alike to the sheltered back bays of Whitewater Bay. Concentrating mostly on the creek mouths where the sweet water meets the salt has been the trick, although the outside beaches of the Cape north into Shark River have been on fire as well.
I’ll see you "On the Flats"
Gear Check
Upon arrival of my new Mirage HPX-V, I was amazed how smooth the Yamaha 90 was as I went through the break-in process. The 256-pound engine weight is a distinct advantage when poling in the shallowest waters of Flamingo and Biscayne Bay, especially with the captain weighting in at 245 pounds!!!!
December 2004
Here we go folks, the winter fishing is in full swing. The recent November cold fronts have done the trick in bringing the winter bite to a full term. Flamingo’s gulf edges are full of Mac’s, cobia, tripletail and snapper and the flats around the inside are teaming with large trout, redfish and snook. December will bring the backcountry of the Everglades alive.
Whitewater Bay will soon be seeing the winter tarpon run and fishing the creek mouths on the northeastern shores are already producing redfish, and snook as well as a great snapper bite. The New Spike-It Holographic Series of plastic baits are responsible for these redfish and snapper we caught in the backcountry. The curly tail pattern in clear does the trick.
As the water in Biscayne Bay cools down you will see the bonefish begin to congregate in larger and larger schools. This is a great advantage to an angler due to the competition factor. When presenting bait or a fly to a school of feeding fish you have a much greater chance of a hook-up. The fish are not as spooky in a school of a dozen or more and will move across a flat in a formation like combat aircraft leaving a very noticeable head wake.
James Dwyer sent me this shot.
A water temp of 72 to 78 degrees is the optimum range for the bonefish, but he will feed in much cooler water, as this 11.5-pound Cutter Bank fish will attest. Jessie Karen and his dad Harvey fished with me with the water temperature around 68 degrees and we did very well. Harvey caught his largest bone ever and had his first two bonefish day.
Permit are still around with the majority of them on the smaller side and in definite schooling patterns. Look for them around the western banks of Biscayne Bay due to the warmer water temperatures that are found there. The darker grass flats will hold the heat from the sun longer. Watch your surface water temperatures very closely during these winter months. If you can find a flat that has a two to three degree temperature rise you will find bonefish and permit on it for sure.
I don’t want to get off on another rant here, but I want to continue to address these issues. One of the things that drive me crazy (or crazier in my case) is the constant running (on plane) over the grass flats. I have a Maverick HPX, and can with my trim tabs down and my engine trimmed up, can run in 8 inches of water without cutting the grass at all. Most of the flats boats in the 18-foot class can run in 12 to 14 inches of water but you should take the time to go around a flat as you are heading for your next spot.
Our flats here have bonefish constantly moving on and off of them throughout the tide flows as they feed. This is why a guide will fish a flat that someone has just moved off of, if he moves off slowly. Poling to the edge of the flat and idling till you have at least two feet of water or more is the best way to ensure that the fish have not been spooked. Taking the time to move off a flat will also ensure that you will not dig a wheel hole when you jump on plane. We all have seen these holes on our flats as well as the long wheel ditches going all the way across, these scars will take years to recover.
The other thing I have been seeing is the crowding of a flat. I have had a boat come down from plane two hundred yards away on my down-wind side. I will do a lot of down wind drifts as we hunt the flats if the sun angle is to our backs, and by coming in on the down-wind side of me is cutting me off and cutting off my fish. Capt. Andy Thompson taught me the lesson of shutting down long before the area I want to fish as not to spook out the flat. You may see bonefish on a flat you run up to but they will be on the offensive from the start. I try to come off plane and start to pole at least one hundred yards before I get to the spot I want to fish as not spook any possible fish that might be there. Tide flow, wind direction and sun angle will dictate how to approach and the direction of drift of a boat on a flat. Consider these three things when approach a flat that has another boat on it.
Larger hull vessels should be aware of the flats anglers as well. When you see a flats boat in the distance it is easy to see if there is a person poling the boat. If there is someone poling, HE IS IN SHALLOW WATER …… DO NOT APPROACH. This is the best indicator that there is a flat in the area, other than the obvious watercolor change. The south end of Biscayne Bay is full of flats and small channels; most of them are ok to navigate with a flats boat but not a 24-foot deep Vee hull with twin outboards. Please check out your chart to find your safest course and help us protect our grassflats.
Hoping all have Happy Holliday’s, and safe days on the water.
Gear CheckI have just received a new Thomas & Thomas Fly rod in a FIFTEEN weight, and am in seventh heaven. I am going to do battle with some very, very large sharks with this stick. I added the new Nautilus 12S fly reel by Old Florida to this new stick I feel I have the best equipment there is to offer my anglers. Come out for a trip and I will show you what I mean.
I have been fishing with some of the new Skitter-Walks from Rapala that Capt. Rick Murphy gave me and I love them. The castability is remarkable, the action is nice and quite on the surface of the water. The rattles add another dimension to fishing the sometimes very dirty waters of Flamingo with fish attracting sounds. Check these baits out at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop or the Complete Angler. My favorite colors are silver mullet, gold mullet and the redfish.
November 2004
Bonefish, Bonefish, Bonefish, this month is the best for my favorite target. With the water staying warm, a 74-degree average, the bones are feeling fall slowly coming on, and with that warm water and the lack of a strong cold front the permit are staying around as well. I have been seeing schools of LARGE bonefish all over the bay and they have been eating on fly as well as bait. A bonefish will always work a flat in an up current direction with his nose into the wind, so to speak. So many we have used the term "bird dogging." A bonefish while swimming into the current will sway back and forth to increase the chance of picking up the scent of a food source. Moving right to left as the fish moves up a flat just like a bird dog working into the wind across a field. It really is a beautiful thing to watch.
Wind direction is as critical as tides when making an approach to a flat. Keep in mind that bonefish as well as redfish have pretty good hearing and become spooky when in shallow situations. Always shut down long before you hit shallow water on your approach to a perspective flat. I will give at least a two hundred yard cushion when coming off plane in an area that I want to fish. Idling in a hundred yards is ok, but keep in mind the noise you make will put the fish on alert if nothing else. This slow approach also gives you a chance to observe the flat and prepare you anglers for the hunt.
When flyfishing for bones on the flats, I change flies almost as often as we change flats. I always try to match the bottom color with my selection of flies as I pull onto a flat. The forage food of the bonefish will adapt a color consistent of the bottom color where they live to better camouflage themselves against being the main course of the day. Fluorocarbon leaders are also a must to fool the bonefish, as well as a well-placed cast of your fly or bait. If you can position yourself in the path of the fish and pull your offering straight away, the leader will be in front of the fly and not visible to the fish.
Allowing your boat to broach (drifting down wind with the boat sideways to the wind) will slow down the speed of your drift. This helps you to see the fish without running over them and at the slower speeds you can also stop the boat for a shot without making a lot of noise and commotion. My Mirage HPX allows me to pole up-wind to a tailing bonefish or redfish without making a sound, yes even in a 20-knot blow. Having a power-Pole is also a distinct advantage; I can drop the Power-Pole and stop the boat while still having my Stiffy push pole in my hand to position my bow for the perfect angle for a presentation of a fly or a better angle to present a shrimp or crab to a fish. Little advantages like these make a big difference when the conditions are against you
Gear Check
My Maverick Mirage HPX is the newest advantage I have against the wary bonefish. I opted for the Vee rather than the Tunnel due to having to cross Biscayne Bay almost every day. The ride it offers is something I can’t tell you about, you have to experience it for yourself to believe. We were throwing High Rollers (Rip-Rollers) at the snook as well as the new Spike-It Holographic plastic baits with great results. Check these new baits out at www.ispikeit.com . Van Demark Custom rods in the 6-12 pound class with Power-Pro 10 pound test lines are the preferred sticks I use spin fishing.. P-Line Fluorocarbon leaders of 30 pound test were a must due the snook activity in the area blowing up schools of mullet along the drop-off of a flat into the channels.
Tight lines & quick releases.
October 2004
The month of September has been a little warmer than most of us fisherpeople would have ordered and with a bunch more hurricanes as well. The normal cold fronts have not been present to help the bait fish start their migratory drive south, but even without the drop in temperatures the bait has arrived, and in good numbers. There’s plenty of mullet in the bay and the fish are responding well.
October has normally seen the infiltration of the bonefish returning to the Biscayne Bay area in force. With the water staying warm, an 82-degree average, the bones are feeling fall slowly coming on, and with that warm water and the lack of a strong cold front the permit should be staying around as well. I have been seeing schools of LARGE bonefish all over the bay and they have been eating on fly as well as bait.
The resident tarpon have re-gathered in the normal haunts to feed on these mullet and we as anglers and guides have been in on the action. Fish the creek mouths on the west side of Biscayne Bay and you will see schools of tarpon, as well as, snook and an occasional school of redfish.
I will fish the "Day on the Bay-Living Legends" tournament sponsored by the Florida Nursery, Growers & Landscapers Association (FNGLA) on October 16th 2004. Kenny St. Germain a world-class fisherman of St. Germain’s Dracaena Farms is this years "Living Legend" This is a great low entry, fun tournament with the proceeds going to the Stan Weyrick Scholarship Fund. Entry fees are only $60 for adults and $15 for junior anglers. For more information on this event please contact Katherine Walters or FNGLA President Capt. Dave Baskin at 305-248-1117. Look for the results in the next report.
As for fishing the bay for bones and permit, there are still good schools of permit to be found on the outgoing tides on the outside of all of the cuts to open water. Wherever there is a good current, just pole up, crush up a few blue crabs, and keep your eyes open. The bones will be a day long hunt with the lowered water temperatures we have, just bring a five gallon bucket of patience with you and plenty of live shrimp, and you will have a great day.
Don’t forget to watch Capt. Dave on the "Chevy’s Florida Fishing Report" every Thursday night at 7 PM on the Sunshine Network. Listen to Capt. Dave on the "Strictly Snook from Florida" radio show on the 790 ESPN Network every Saturday Morning at 7 AM for great guests and up to date fishing reports.
Hoping all is well, with all of the fuss from the hurricanes that is going on around us. Our spirit has never been more banded together than when our brothers & sisters are in need, after all, we are all Americans!
I’ll see you "On the Flats"
Capt. Dave Sutton
September Report 2004
First off let me say that my prayers are with all the folks affected by Hurricane Charlie. As a guide who went through Hurricane Andrew, I have a pretty good idea what you folks are up against and believe me when I tell you there are thousands of people who are rallying to your aid RIGHT KNOW !!!! Don’t think for a minute that you are alone. Your fellow Americans will be there for you in your time of need. The Youth Fishing Foundation is just one of many who is organizing supplies and making two trips a week to the affected areas with hurricane relief items and will keep on doing it till you are back on your feet. So keep the faith brothers & sisters.
With all of the hurricanes around the fishing has been tough. Windy conditions make for a tactical approach to fishing the flats of Biscayne Bay, or even Flamingo for that matter. Wind direction is as critical as tides when making an approach to a flat. Keep in mind that bonefish as well as redfish have pretty good hearing and become spooky when in shallow situations. Always shut down long before you hit shallow water on your approach to a perspective flat. I will give at least a two hundred yard cushion when coming off plane in an area that I want to fish. Idling in a hundred yards is ok, but keep in mind the noise you make will put the fish on alert if nothing else. This slow approach also gives you a chance to observe the flat and prepare you anglers for the hunt.
I have seen too many fisherman run too close to a flat and then wonder why there are no fish on it, or why the fish are so spooky when they do see fish. Have you ever approached a flat that has another boat on it and have the person polling start waving his arms? Most of the flatsmen you see on a flat will do a down sun, down wind drift depending the tide flow. Drifting with the wind and with the sun at his back makes the visibility in front of the boat the best for sight fishing. DO NOT enter a flat downwind of someone who is already on there, you will be cutting off his drift and hence the arm waving. Take up a position up-wind of him and start your drift to one side or the other. This will give him his room and also give you a chance to intercept fish that got by him. Most of the time, if you watch him close, he will point out fish to his angler or even to you as he makes his way down the flat.
Here is the new 2005, 2400 Pathfinder
I know I stated a few months ago I was going to get into the gulf fishing more with another hull but I have been testing this new 2400 by Pathfinder with Tackle Testers International and have been totally amazed. This hull is over 400 pounds lighter than the other hull I was looking at, runs faster, gets much better fuel mileage and rides just as good if not a little bit better. My new hull will have a 300 HPDI Yamaha and will be a quick runner to get back from the white spots and wrecks of the Gulf in no time at all.
Working with Jim Wyborg of Bob Hewes Boats at 12565 NW 7th Ave in North Miami has been a great experience. With three different locations any maintenance issues are no longer a matter of driving a half-day. Give them a call at 305-681-6602 to check out the great line of Pathfinders and Hewes Boats. Look for an article in the next issue of Outdoor Florida on the newest hull by Hewes. We at Tackle Testers are testing it right know and are very pleased with the preliminary results.
Gear Check
My Maverick Mirage HPX is now going to be Yamaha Powered and is the best advantage I have against the wary bonefish. I opted for the Vee rather than the Tunnel due to having to cross Biscayne Bay almost every day. The ride it offers is something I can’t tell you about, you have to experience it for yourself to believe. We were throwing High Rollers (Rip-Rollers) at the snook as well as the new Strike-it soft plastic baits I found at ICast this year with great results using the Quantum Cabo rods & reels in the 8-12 pound class with Power-Pro 10 pound test lines. P-Line Fluorocarbon leaders of 30 pound test were a must due the snook activity in the area blowing up schools of mullet along the drop-off of a flat into the channels.
Tight lines and remember to practice "Catch & Release" as
much as possible rather than "Fillet & Release" and I will see you "On the
Flats"
August Report 2004
Summer is almost gone with the dog days of August here. The fishing has been very good this season in Biscayne Bay. Permit have been overrunning the flats inside and outside of the bay with some very large fish being caught. Targeting permit on spin is a real treat; I start off at the bait shop. Rather than getting five-dozen shrimp and a couple of crabs like I do most of the rest of the year, I order two-dozen crabs and a dozen shrimp. The first dozen of crabs should be the size of a quarter for the large bones and smaller permit, and the second dozen should be the size of a silver dollar. The larger crabs will give you longer casts for the tailing fish and the fish over fifteen pounds will eat them up like M&M’s.
During these calm and quiet days on the flats remember to step down to a lighter weight rod for a softer presentation to the fish. My eight-weight rod is my preferred rod during those windy days, but most of the summer I throw a seven to the bonefish. On occasion, I will use a six weight on a school of smaller fish like we often see on the outside of the bay along Elliot key and up to the Ragged keys and south to Garden Cove. These schools of fish are smaller than the Arsnicker fish and can easily be managed with a lighter rod. Did I mention it’s a lot more fun on a lighter rod as well! Just keep your angles opposite the fish’s direction and apply the pressure from the first two feet of the rod, rather than the tip, to reduce a long, drawn out fight.
Don’t forget the snook season opens Sept. one ….
Can’t wait. Call to book now!!!!!!
We also tag fish for the University of Miami Research Program. I have been on the program for almost four years now and have gotten a lot of information from the research they are performing. If you noticed I don’t tag all of the fish I catch, as is my standard practice. I will only tag a bone that has been landed in the best of shape to lessen the impact on the fish. I will take a lot of time reviving every fish caught to ensure the fish has had a chance to recover from the fight before releasing him. I hope you all practice the same care when releasing a one of our precocious bonefish.
Gear Check
The gear we are using these days "On the Flats" with Capt. Dave is the Custom rod from VanDemark Rods. These rods are seven-foot six inches long, medium action rods made for 6-14 pound test lines, matched with the new Quantum Cabo 30 reel filled with 10-pound test Power-Pro Braid line. The Eagle Claw 2/0 circle hooks worked perfectly with all of the hooks lodged firmly in the corner of the mouth textbook style, use a 4/0 on the larger crabs. The mono leader I will always run from the braid to the hook was 36 inches of P-Line Fluorocarbon leader material in 25-pound test. The lighter the leader the better for the black eyed permit, but when you get into the fish 25 pounds plus and with the combination of large sea fans in the area I will go to a 15 pound Power-Pro rig with 36" of 30 pound leader to increase the chances of a photo finish.
Tight lines & quick releases, and I will see you "On The Flats"
July Report 2004
As July approaches we will see the water temperatures rising still to the point of driving the bonefish off the flats during the middle of the day, although the permit will be showing more and more as the waters warm. Target your bonefishing on those days of an early morning, incoming tide. The influx of cooler water flooding the flats will turn on the bite and give you a better chance of hooking the grey ghost of the flats.

Here is my #1 angler Harvey Karen w/his Grand Slam
This is the best time to try for the Grand Slam of the flats. To catch a bone, permit and tarpon in the same day is very possible during the three months of summer. Permit being the toughest of the three to get to eat, this is the time of year the greatest numbers of fish gather on our flats. Target them with a 1 ½ " crab on a 2/0 circle hook, at least a 30 pound fluorocarbon leader and hold on for the fight of your life. Have your boat captain keep fairly close to help keep the line out of the fan coral and ff the bottom for your best chances to keep a fish on.
When flyfishing for bones on the flats, I change flies almost as often as we change flats. I always try to match the bottom color with my selection of flies as I pull onto a flat. The forage food of the bonefish will adapt a color consistent of the bottom color where they live to better camouflage themselves against being the main course of the day. Fluorocarbon leaders are also a must to fool the bonefish, as well as a well-placed cast of your fly or bait. If you can position yourself in the path of the fish and pull your offering straight away, the leader will be in front of the fly and not visible to the fish.
Tarpon will still be very much present in our waters, and in good numbers now that they have ended the spawning cycle. They will be much more aggressive feeders now since they don’t eat much during the spawn. The cockroach patterns have been very successful in the early parts of the day and as the sun climbs higher in the sky, switch to a chartreuse or white and yellow combination for the best results. I’m hearing more and more that circle hooks are being used rather than the old standard hooks for a better catch percentage. Just fight the urge to strike and set the hook, with the circle hooks all you need do is lift the rod to lodge the hook in the corner of the mouth and in the ensuing fight the hook will be imbedded deep enough to land the fish. Please take the time to revive the fish properly after you land one of these friends of mine to ensure their survival. They are just too valuable to catch only once.
The ICAST Show is in Las Vegas this year and your captain will be attending, so look for a report in the August issue for the lowdown on this fishing manufacturers convention. All the products for the sport will be there and it will be held July 14th thru the 16th. I am sure I’ll have a few new products to tell you about.
Until next month, I’ll see you " On the Flats"
June Report 2004
June is here and I am hoping the winds have subsided for this spring season. It has been a constant battle with the 25 to 30 knot blow we have had for the past months, but I have cautioned you about staying home and not fishing. The wind gives you an advantage if you know how to use it. Here is a perfect example of finding good fish in bad situations…we were throwing Gambler soft plastics rigged weedless style in ten inches of milky water. We were having a hard time seeing the weed lines, never mind the fish ……
Fishing Biscayne Bay on an east wind is tough but not impossible. Use the wind to do DOWN-WIND drifts over your favorite flats. Allow your boat to broach, meaning drift sideways in the wind, this will slow your drift down to a reasonable speed for sighting bones and permit. If poling, pole 90 degrees to the wind in the morning with your bow pointing north with an east wind. Your speed will be manageable and you can cover some ground as you hunt for big fish.
Fishing the Rolex IGFA World Championship the first week of May was a challenge in the winds we had throughout the month. On the first day of competition we decided to go to Biscayne Bay for permit and bones. Upon shutting down on our first flat we had a school of permit round the point and come straight at us. My angler’s first cast was perfect but the wind left such a bow in the line he couldn’t feel the permit chewing the shrimp off his hook. We even had time to re-bait and try another shot, but alas the same scenario occurred. Throughout the day we had a few more good opportunities but just couldn’t capitalize on them returning to the dock after running over 90 miles with a bagel, zilch, nada …. ZIP.
Day two was much better scoring three snook on artificial (all over 30") and three redfish as well. Day three scoring one snook and two redfish for a three-day grand total for my three anglers of 675 points. Robert Collins (This years winner of the Herman Lucerne) won TOP Angler with 1300 points.
Fishing Flamingo during the last two months of windy conditions forced me to learn the flats I thought I knew so well in a much different light. As the water drained out during the outgoing tides I realized the importance of staying in the zones I thought had fish. Having the confidence to continue to fish as the wind emptied the whole area into a couple of washes is the secret to success in the type of weather we have had.
If you tell yourself that catching a couple of snook and red’s would make the day, why not commit to an area that you know will be productive and fish it hard. These areas we all know like around Frank, Palm and the area I call Jimmies Lake. These areas will hold fish when the entire flats drain during a low tide made worse by a strong east wind. Just have the patience to stay on the spot and work for those fish and you will be rewarded for your efforts.
Don’t forget to listen to 790 AM WAXY Radio on Sunday nights for my new fishing show "Strictly Snook From Florida" between 8 & 9 PM for the latest in snook fishing as well as all of the other shallow water species. We will have fishing reports from some of the experts from Chevy’s Florida Fishing Reports like Ron Hueston, the Southwestern Expert and Mike Holliday, the Southeastern Expert so don’t miss it.
Tight Lines and I will see you "On the Flats"
May Report 2004
Well the winds have not calmed down yet but the bite has drastically improved in the bay as the water temperatures raise. The bonefish have been very present all over the bay in large schools, all the way down the Upper Keys. I have seen schools in the twenties out on the inside of the Ragged Keys south down to Garden Cove flats. Inside of Rabbit key Basin has gotten much better as of late as well, with reports of large schools moving on the strong tides. Look for tailers at the end of the falling tides as well as the first of the incoming tides on the outside of Elliot all along the deep edges. The bones will be working the lower waters and stay just deep enough while waiting for the water to rise up onto the flats, but keep an eye out for permit in the 2 to 3 foot water as the tide rises. Look for these scenario’s to just get better as the water warms to and over the 80-degree mark.
The Tarpon are moving south along the outside of Key Largo all along the shore up to Sands Cut in good numbers and have been eaters on tans and light browns early in the day and chartreuse to olive patterns midday. There have been good numbers of tarpon moving on the outer edges of Florida Bay’s First National Bank as well all the way down to Springer Bank. Look for rollers and get in front of them and take a shot. The patterns are a closely kept secret between the guides and to ask them for the color is your only hope. The colors I have had luck on are the same as listed above in the Bay, just add a yellow and white in the mix for the midday bite
Have you seen the new Sunshine Network Show "Chevy’s Florida Fishing Reports" This new show has our own Capt. Rick Murphy as a co-host and yours truly, Capt. Dave Sutton as the "South Regional Expert" The show divides Florida into seven regions with each of these regions having an expert that gives an offshore as well as an inshore report each week on the Sunshine Network between 7 & 8 PM on Thursday night. There is also a very detailed fisherman’s weather report for the upcoming weekend, so check it out. Next month I will give you the listing of the guides, the "Magnificent Seven" Experts ALL around the state.
Something else is NEW>>> look for a new radio show called "Strictly Snook from Florida" This is a new talk show dealing with, well, Snook of course as well as all of the other inshore species we all know and love. The Host will be radio personality Tim Mullins and the Co-Host will be ….. that’s right …. you guessed it …Capt. Dave Sutton.
Our first airing will be Sunday May 16th between 8 & 9 PM on WAXY 790 AM. We will be having some of your favorite guides on the show giving reports as well as the top authorities in the preservation of Snook here in Florida. Also having some of the fisherman who love to fish for Snook from bridges, canals, jetty’s, docks and piers on the show will make for a very interesting show. The phones will be live for your interaction. Stay tuned for more info…. Until then, I’ll see you "On the Flats"
April Report 2004
Hopefully the March winds have left with the passing of March and we can get down to some of our normal drifts. My Maverick HPX-V has been a blessing in these winds giving me the ability to pole into a stiff wind without killing myself.
I hope all of you have been finding the permit as well as I have this past month. Fishing with Rob Mallin from Village Office Supply in New Jersey for two days, Rob said, "Having a double permit with a bonefish on at the same time is a very exciting thing". Both anglers were fishing the South Florida flats for the first time and with a little coaching the two-day score was two permit and a bone.
With a good wind comes a little security for the flats inhabitants. The bones and permit tend to really eat well during a 20-knot wind. True, it is a little harder to see them, but on the other hand it is also harder for them to see us. The wind also covers the splash down of your offering much better. If you have ever tried to land a shrimp near a tailing bonefish in flat calm water, you know what I mean. Most of the time you get the reaction that you have hit him in the head with a baseball or something. So if it’s blowing, don’t hesitate to go fishing, you will be happy you did.
Look for the permit to be in the two to three foot ranges along the bonefish flats as they follow mudding rays. This is one of the easiest ways of spotting fish and a great chance to approach those fish when they have their attention focused on something other than your approach or if there are any sharks around. Work an edge looking shallow for bones as well as deep for the chance of a shot at a permit and you will be pleasantly surprised.
There is a new cash prize in the Herman Lucerne this year we have unknowingly left out of our press releases. The "TOP GUIDE" award this year will come with a check for $1000.00. This new cash award was designed to entice all of you guides out there to get your favorite anglers to participate in this great event. Remind them that the tournament benefits the Children’s Pediatric Services of the Homestead Hospital and it should be an easy sell. This years ditty bags are also shaping up to be the best ever. With donations from MadMan Baits, High Rollers, P-Line, Eagle Claw Hooks, Hawaiian Tropics, Florida Sportsman’s Tide Magazine plus the come back of our long sleeve Herman Lucerne tee shirt, we have the very best. Put those items together with an embroidered angler shirt & hat, a clear dry bag, fish fry on Friday night at the captains Meeting in Homestead, a full Awards Banquet on Sunday night at Keys Gate Golf & Country Club and you will se this tournament is one of the premier contests in South Florida. Hope to see you there.
Gear Check
Now is the time to get out your 11 & 12 weight fly rods to prepare for the Tarpon runs of spring. You can loosen up in Whitewater Bay blind casting for the kings to get yourself into the rhythm of throwing the heavy rods again. Clean your reels and lines then check your backing and don’t forget to throw out any old rusty hooked tarpon flies. See Franco at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop for the latest patterns and "lets get it on"!!!!
I had decided to do a little more Gulf of Mexico fishing and I needed a larger hull to do the trips in comfort. This combination should be just perfect. During the Miami International Boat Show this year I took the time to check out EVERY 22’ to 24’ bay boat to see what was offered by the industry. I have come to the conclusion that the Triton has the best deck layout, the best fit & finish and far and above, the best ride on the market. Come for a test ride with me and I think you will agree. Anglers Marine of Ft. Lauderdale is my new Dealership for the Triton ... Why? SERVICE, SERVICE, and SERVICE I’ll see you "On the Flats"
March Report 2004
Miami’s Biscayne Bay has been full of bonefish and should continue to get even better as the month of March approaches. Water temperatures have been in the mid-seventies between the cold fronts and the winds have been maintaining a somewhat easterly direction making for perfect conditions on the bay. Landing nine bonefish while only fishing for them for two day’s in the past twenty is a testament to the availability of working fish. The bones have been active all over the bay with the water temperatures over the 72-degree mark, from the west bay all around the Chicken Key area south to the north end of Key Largo. Large schools of fish are up on the flats and feeding very well. I have been on many nice schools of fish over on the east side of the bay from Cesar’s Creek south to Angelfish & Broad Creeks as well. With the opening of snook season this February 1st we have targeted linesiders in the bay as well. Look in the creek mouths, canal mouths and channel entrances during an outgoing tide for the bets shots.
Winter Tarpon is in full swing from the bridges of Miami all the way over the Florida Bay and Flamingo. Whitewater Bay has been a frequent haunt for many anglers throwing HighRollers and Bagley’s mullet baits for the Kings. Landing two fish a day has been the average, although you need to jump another five to seven fish to keep the odds this good. Casting poppers and shallow divers is a lot of fun for these giants, especially when they take a swing at your lure five feet away from the boat. Remember, natural colors in clean water and bright colors in dirty water has been the measure of success on my boat this season. Throwing a fly has only been done by the die-hard anglers who can stand up to blind casting in a fifteen-knot wind for a chance of jumping some nice fish. As tuff as it may sound, this has been the tactics that has landed eight fish over eighty pounds in the last month.
Snook and redfish are all over the backcountry of Flamingo as well as the outside flats into Florida Bay, but slow down your presentations with the cold waters after a cold front. Black drum are a day saver when the water temperatures are below the 65-degree mark. Use a troll-right jig tipped with a live shrimp and you will be surprised. Cobia and tripletail are on the crab pot buoys and the Spanish macks are in full force out in the deep waters of the gulf. If you are planning a guided trip here in So. Florida there isn’t a better time to go than now
Gear Check
Now is the time to get out your 11 & 12 weight fly rods to prepare for the Tarpon runs of spring. You can loosen up in Whitewater Bay blind casting for the kings to get yourself into the rhythm of throwing the heavy rods again. Clean your reels and lines then check your backing and don’t forget to throw out any old rusty hooked tarpon flies. See Franco at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop for the latest patterns and "lets get it on"!!!!
I’ll see you "On the Flats"
February Report 2004
Well the cold fronts have become a weekly tradition this past January and look like they might follow into February. It has been a mixed bag of windy days and cold fronts blowing through from the west and north making the bonefishing very tough. With the sudden drop of five degrees in water temperature the bones retreat to the deeper flats and forage there, rather than suffer the cold water on the shallower flats. It will take two or three days in succession to bring them back to tailing water. Watch the surface temps and get ready to fish. I have found that the magic number seems to be 68 degrees until the bonefish will begin to migrate onto the skinny water to feed.
Young tarpon on the other hand can be found in the same cuts and channels during the cold fronts and a well placed shrimp will produce an eruption on the surface that is almost as good as their larger fellows of spring. These young fish like to school and look for the safest hiding spots from the sharks. Fish the hollows under the mangrove shoreline and keep a sharp eye out for snook as well. Any little creek mouth flow that is out of the normal hustle and bustle of traffic will hold fish as long as the flow is coming out of the creek and into deeper water. Also start looking for the big brothers as they come into the Everglades Backcountry.
The flyfishing for bones is still worth trying if you use a fly with weighted eyes and allow it to fall to at least three feet before starting to strip. I like to use clousers and Borski’s Fur Shrimp for this due to the upward bent hook design of the fly and it’s sparse tie to help the sink rate. Colors we use are white and light tan, white and chartreuse and white and yellow. These colors seam to be the best bet for the deep edges of the channel when you see mudding bonefish.
February will show a few more of these cold fronts and with it the blustery winds of early spring to deal with as well. Try to work a specific flat for bonefish over and over again and you will see that there is a general set of conditions that will bring schools of fish to the flat. Wind direction, tide flow, tide time of day and of course the position of the moon. All of these factors dictate whether you will see a few tailers or a few schools of tailers. But most importantly, be patient and enjoy the hunt, even if the score is lopsided. This is called fishing and even the very best guides will return to the dock at times with a final score of bonefish 8 & anglers nothing, every once and a while.
I’ll see you "On the Flats"
January Report 2004
The cold fronts of winter have arrived, and in force. Water temperatures are down in the mid sixties and the bonefish are responding. Tailing will only occur late in the day after a calm, sunny afternoon has a chance to warm to waters two to five degrees. A temperature rise will trigger a late feed in water shallow enough to see tails. For the most part target fish on the deeper edges of flats and during the higher stages of the tides. Look for mudding fish in two to four feet of water and you will be pleasantly surprised.
Most of my fishing has been in the backcountry of Flamingo this past December. The weather has brought most of the anglers and guides alike to the sheltered back bays of Whitewater Bay. Concentrating mostly on the creek mouths where the sweet water meets the salt has been the trick, although the outside beaches of the cape north into Shark River have been on fire as well.
While on a busman’s holiday fishing with Capt. Eric VanDemark we were set up on the south bank of Conche Channel with a chum bag looking for pinfish and pilchards. I noticed a large shark coming up the chum slick for a look at the source. "Look at the size of that Lemon Shark bud" I said to Eric, as he looked at the shark out about forty feet and closing. We both noticed a pattern emerging on the sides of the seven-foot long fish as the shark got closer and closer to the chum bag I was shaking. "That’s a Tiger Shark" Eric said with an excited voice as he dashed for a rod. I backed off the bow just a little as the shark nosed the chum bag and turned off circling back for another run at it. I kept the tease on till Eric got ready with some of the fresh bait we had just caught, and upon hooking up the great fish for the third time the fight was on.
This was about as close as I was going to get to this dude especially without a LONG wire leader. The Tiger showed no fear of the boat at all and kept on eating Eric’s baits even after he had hooked the fish twice. This was the first time we had ever seen a Tiger here in South Florida waters. Being flats fisherman, and spending most of our time in twelve inches of water, I am not surprised. I’m sure there are plenty of them offshore but to see one in three feet of water was a surprise.
There have been lots of fish on the outside wrecks as well. Making the trip out ten to fifteen miles from the Shark River or Sandy Key has been a gamble. The choice must be made on the right day to make the trip or the ride back can be very uncomfortable even in a twenty plus foot hull, but the trip is worth it. Large Snapper, Grouper, Black Drum, Tripletail, Cobia and a host of other species await you. Just use your best judgment and of course, the weather reports, and you will have plenty of work to do at the cleaning table upon your return. I’ll see you "On the Flats"
Tournament Report
ISLAMORADA, Florida Keys
… Last year Bonnie Christ won the lady grand champion title in the Mercury Outboards/Cheeca Redbone Celebrity Tournament. This year, the Alexandria, Va. Executive became the first woman in the 16-year history of the tournament to capture the grand champion title outright among the 134-angler field.Guided by Mercury pro team Capt. Andy Thompson of Homestead, Christ caught four bonefish Saturday and four redfish Sunday, all on bait, to make four combinations of "redbones." She took home a stainless steel Rolex timepiece along with artwork as a part of her winnings in the awards ceremony at Cheeca Lodge.
To further cap off the celebrity charity event that helps fund research efforts for cystic fibrosis, Christ and fishing partner Joe Viar, also from Alexandria and both long time supporters of the tournaments, won the team grand championship title with three bonefish Viar released. Christ also released the most bonefish for that award.
Considering the cold front that dropped temperatures and brought windy conditions to the Florida Bay waters on Saturday, Christ’s performance was considered remarkable. "It was one of those memorable days," Christ said, "like the time I caught three permit in a day."
On Sunday she listened to Capt’n Thompson’s instructions to pick up extra points for redfish and bonefish combinations by "catching four redfish today". Christ released all four redfish before lunch in two different places and in different ways sight-casting for some and blind-casting into troughs for others. Kudos’ to Capt Andy Thompson
December Report 2003
Hopefully the winds of November will fade to a manageable ten to fifteen knots for December. Bonefishing has been tough in the twenty plus winds we have had, but the fish are there. Time and time again in the Bay I have been lucky enough to be at the right place at the right time and have a three bonefish day. The water temperatures are just right fir the feeding frenzies I have been able to pole into on Cutter Bank, the Rubicon’s and the outside flats of Elliot Key.
Have you seen the sunken shrimp boat just to the east of the ICW, north of Cutter bank? How long is the National Park going to allow it to sit on the grass beds with it’s shrimp nets strewn all over the bottom. As I am writing this it has been there for a week with only a couple of red buoys to mark the nets. Seems to me those nets would be a hindrance to fish in the area, I am just hoping my bonefish stay clear of the hazard.
I have been finding that there is still a few permit on the outside flats. We went down to the old Carysfort Marina and if you go just southeast about two hundred yards there is a shallow flat about two feet during the low tide. I have been finding most of my permit there with a few tarpon passing by as well. If you check out your charts you will find quite a few spots like this one that will hold permit till the water temperatures drop to below 70 degrees. After that they will move out onto the wrecks in deep water which is there wintering grounds.
For all of those who have asked about my new skiff I am building, she is coming along real nice. John from Release Boats has offered me the use of his lay-up tables to do the bulkheads, floors and top cap. This will give me that professional finish I am looking for without all the expense of making tables myself. Plus the all-important experience of using them, which are skills I haven’t mastered … yet! I will have a few pics after the holidays for your inspection in the January Edition.
I hope you all have a very happy and safe Holiday Season,
and I will see you "On the Flats"
Tournament Update
The 2003 Florida Nursery Growers Association’s "Living Legends Tournament" (formally known as the Day on the Bay) was another success this year. Raising over $10K this year for college students while honoring one of the most respected members of our community Colleen Boggs, the tournament is it’s third year. I had the Top Female and Top Junior on my boat this year, hence the top Guide Award. There were also twelve other trophies awarded for largest fish as well as the Slam Awards.
This years top winners were;
Top Male Angler …. John Sanchez of Blaylock Oil with 64 inches
Top Female Angler …. Julie Sutton Marine Artist with 77.5 inches
Top Junior Angler …. Eric Durnberg with 35 inches (MY ANGLER)
Top Guide …. Capt. Dave Sutton
Other notable awards went to Julie Sutton for Largest Trout, Mike Stasko for Largest Bonefish and our honored Living Legend, Colleen Boggs for Largest Snapper. Fifty-one anglers participated this year and made the tournament a smashing hit.
A real big Thank-you to all of our sponsors who made this tournament possible.
The First Annual Ocean Reef Bonefish & Tarpon Unlimited Backbone Classic will be held at the Ocean Reef Club December 2-4 2003. Formally known as the Boy Scout Backbone, this tournament is one of the most enjoyable contests I have had the pleasure to guide. Scoring is set up to allow even the novice angler a chance to place up with the seasoned veterans, and the venue is the most elegant we have here in the South Florida Area. I am fishing my sponsors from Florida Hiway & Marine Insurance again this year and we hope to place well again this year. Sponsors include Scout Boats, Mercury Outboards, Renzetti Vises, with artwork by CD Clark, Luther Hall & Tim Borski. There will be a multitude of destination trips to places like Mangrove Key, Tropic Star Lodge in Costa Rica and a trip to the Seychelles. Don’t miss this event, if you need more information call the Tournament Director Jack Curlett @ 305-522-0745 or Lisa Crayne @ 305-367-5896. I will see you there!!!!
Gear Check
I have just received my new Thomas & Thomas Fly rods and am in seventh heaven. I had a chance to throw my new 8 & 9 weights during the high winds of the November and am just amazed at the power I now hold in my hand. When I added the new Nautikos fly reels by Old Florida to these new sticks I feel I have the best equipment there is to offer my anglers. Come out for a trip and I will show you what I mean.
I have been fishing with some of the new Skitter-Walks from Rapala that Capt. Rick Murphy gave and I love them. The castability is remarkable, the action is nice and quite on the surface of the water. The rattles add another dimension to fishing the sometimes very dirty waters of Flamingo with fish attracting sounds. Check these baits out at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop or the Complete Angler. My favorite colors are silver mullet, gold mullet and the redfish.
November Report 2003
Fishing Biscayne Bay during November will be an exercise in wind resistance, and it’s just starting. Through the winter till maybe April the wind is your foremost adversary on the flats. Just learn the flats in your area and the different drifts you will need to do during different wind directions, and you will start to see a pattern emerging. The bonefish use the same routes to enter and feed on a flat. Depending on the current direction and if it is a tidal current of one dictated by the wind and it’s direction, you will se the patterns. Just watch for those tails working and get ready for some action!!!!!
A bonefish will always be heading in an up current direction with his nose into the wind, so to speak. So many times I have used the term "bird dogging" to describe a bonefish while swimming into the current, he will sway back and forth to increase the chance of picking up the scent of a food source. Moving right to left as the fish moves up a flat just like a bird dog working into the wind across a field. It really is a beautiful thing to watch.
Tour winter flats only after a couple of cold fronts have passed through the area to see if the fish have been active on them. By winter flats I mean the darker colored grass flats that would warm up quicker than those lighter colored bottoms. If you don’t see fish in the ten to twelve inch water range, move off the flat a little and look for mud’s in the two foot range. Sometimes the lower water temperatures will keep the fish from the tailing water and move them into deeper water due to more stable temperatures.
When flyfishing for bones on the flats, I change flies almost as often as we change flats. I always try to match the bottom color with my selection of flies as I pull onto a flat. The forage food of the bonefish will adapt a color consistent of the bottom color where they live to better camouflage themselves against being the main course of the day. Fluorocarbon leaders are also a must to fool the bonefish, as well as a well-placed cast of your fly or bait. If you can position yourself in the path of the fish and pull your offering straight away, the leader will be in front of the fly and not visible to the fish.
This is the best time to try for the Grand Slam of the flats. To catch a bone, permit and tarpon in the same day is very possible. Permit being the toughest of the three to get to eat, at this time of year the greatest numbers of fish gather on our outside flats on an outgoing tide. Target them with a 1 ½ " crab on a 2/0 circle hook, at least a 20 pound fluorocarbon leader and hold on for the fight of your life. Have your captain keep fairly close to help keep the line out of the fan coral and off the bottom for your best chances to keep a fish on.
My new boat is going very well with the outside glasswork done and the interior Kevlar bottom just installed, I am ready to go to the lay-up table and start the bulkheads & decks. Here are a couple of shots of my progress.
I will keep you up to date while I continue to build this skiff. I am hoping the weight will be less than 250 lbs. so a Mercury 25 HP. Tiller will be enough to push her. If I can hold to this projected weight she should draft three to four inches of water with ten gallons of fuel and two anglers. Well, I will see you "On The Flats"
Gear Check
Here is the reason I don’t mind fishing in the rain. Frogg Toggs are a 100% waterproof, windproof, lightweight breathable outerwear that everyone can afford. These guys have pioneered the use of Microporous Polypropylene fabric’s and the "NO-NEEDLE" seam for NO-LEAKING.
This rain gear is by far the best I have ever used, just ask any of my anglers who have used the on-board gear on my boat. They will tell you they have gone out and bought there own set. "This stuff is as light as paper" I hear all of the time, but it is super-strong. I have had a set on my skiff for over a year, and that’s a lot of abuse !!!!!
Check out the gear at www.froggtoggs.com
October Report 2003
Bonefish, Bonefish, Bonefish, this month is the best for my favorite target. With the water staying warm, an 84-degree average, the bones are feeling fall slowly coming on, and with that warm water and the lack of a strong cold front the permit are staying around as well. I have been seeing schools of LARGE bonefish all over the bay and they have been eating on fly as well as bait.
A bonefish will always be heading in an up current direction with his nose into the wind, so to speak. So many we have used the term "bird dogging." A bonefish while swimming into the current will sway back and forth to increase the chance of picking up the scent of a food source. Moving right to left as the fish moves up a flat just like a bird dog working into the wind across a field. It really is a beautiful thing to watch.The Redfish Tour in Jacksonville was all new ground for Ron Sprague and myself. We loved the four to five foot tides and the current flow that was happening, we found it to be remarkable. Running along the Intercoastal north from the Saint John’s River the Spartina grass flats were vast and beautiful. We had a full moon two day’s before the event and the flats would flood allowing the redfish the chance to get really get shallow and tail away, but when the tide dropped, IT REALLY DROPPED. The current in the backwater bays was four to five knots of ripping outgoing water. It went from a beautiful flooded grass flat to mud flats with oyster bars towering above up to four feet tall. The first time we saw the low tide we were shocked that we were only three hours ago running on plane across these oyster bars doing thirty knots. If you ever get a chance to fish this fishery, don’t pass it up.
We caught some great fish on High Rollers, but found it much harder during the competition due to the lack of strong tides after the full moon. Many teams went without a fish for the two-day tournament. We struggled for a 69th place finish.
I have been a woodworker for over 25 years doing finish woodwork for a living before I retired to a life of guiding. I have built hand made wood canoes using the stripping method for years.
My newest creation will be a 17’8" ultra shallow draft poling skiff made to handle a 25 HP outboard, Mercury of course. The beam is 48" and the draft should be three to four inches with fuel and two anglers. I have installed a small tunnel for shallow running and the ability to jump out of twelve inches of water without disturbing the bottom.
Yes, I have decided to make her out of wood for the beauty of it all. The outside hull will be fibreglassed with West System Epoxy Resin for strength and it’s flexibility, and remains clear to show off the wood. The inside will be done in Kevlar for its strength as well as its lightness. All bulkheads, lower decks and casting decks will be done in fiberglass core cell foam for the lightest possible completed hull.
Well, I will keep you informed on my progress and hope to see you on the wall in Snakebite in two months. Until then I’ll see you "On the Flats"
Gear Check
After the Flyfishers Retail Show in Denver I have a new Sponsor. My new 8 wt. Thomas & Thomas rod with the new Old Florida Nautilus #8 reel was the best combination I threw during the show, and I threw them all. I have been testing this new Old Florida Nautilus reel for a while and have found it to be the very best reel I have ever used, teamed up with the T & T I have an awesome combination. The Redfish Tour gear was my Cape Fear rods in 8 to 15 pound class with the Finn-Nor Mega-Lites in the 4000 size loaded with the NEW 15 pound Power-Pro line. We were throwing mostly Mad-Man Saltwater Baits with a few High Rollers and we even went to the old trusty Johnson’s Gold Spoons. Tight lines & quick releases.
September Report 2003
September is upon us again with the familiar warm evenings and wonderful sunsets after our seasonable afternoon thunderstorms. Snook season has opened and the hunt is on for the linesiders. There are still plenty of fish on the beaches and creek mouths of Florida Bay. I have been up in the bites, you know Garfield, Rankin and that whole shoreline all the way to the dragover with lots of luck. Young tarpon in the five-pound class rolling about, snook taking top water Rip Rollers, redfish tailing in the very skinny waters, it is the time to pole. The winds are minimal this time of year making it a time to just pole along slowly in six to eight inches of water looking for pushes and waking fish.
Lets talk real skinny water for a minute. Whether you are in Biscayne Bay or Florida Bay some of the very best times I have had guiding a client is in six to eight inches of water. Biscayne Bay and it’s bonefish tailing on the last of an outgoing tide trying to get the last feed on before Cutter Bank goes dry is what’s its all about for me. Pushing my Maverick along leaving a vee pattern in the grass flats trying to get close enough to make a cast at a twelve pounder that is just tailing like there is no tomorrow, this is the very essence of flats fishing. To be on the outside of Caesar’s Creek at a dead low just as the tide starts to flow in over the south side flats, the permit will be just on the edges of the cut. They will work up and down those edges, then as the water level rises to the point of they’re being just enough water, they will tail on the shallow flat as they feed. The tails will look like black fillet knife blades as they stick out of the water darting along.
Pushing over the hump on Snake bite flat as the tide floods the flat, the grass is slowly disappearing, and as the first wave of mullet start mudding is when the first redfish and snook will slowly follow them. You have seen the bait being flushed out of the water as the sharks tear into the mullet...well it isn’t always a shark doing that. There will be plenty of snook, redfish and of course large seatrout in the mix as well. But you need the shallow draft and silence of a top quality hull to get close enough.
Some of the hulls that can do this with ease are of course the Maverick HPX-V (my ride) and HPX-Tunnel hulls, most of the Hell’s Bay series of skiffs, and the Pathfinder Tunnel Hull. Many people use an aluminum hull for this kind of fishing but I have found these hulls to be very noisy as well as providing a horrendous ride in a chop. But then again some of the aforementioned tunnels ride very ruff in a chop but the advantage is they are silent and draft only a few inches when it is most needed, when "sight fishing".
The shallow water and stillness of this water even in a fifteen to twenty knot wind makes approaching a game fish very difficult. Part of the key is to approach very slowly with very little movement from you as the guide poling and from your angler. This type of "sight fishing" requires very short accurate casting and buckets of patience but the dividends are priceless. One trick to having the visibility of the guy on the tower is to have a front casting platform, or you can take your cooler and stand on it on the bow. This will elevate you sixteen to eighteen inches and you will not believe the difference. Just remember the fish can see you better as well. Keep your movements down to a minimum, when you see a fish go a crouching position to make your cast, and cast from the side rather than overhead. Just the movement of your rod can spook fish in eight inches of clear water.
Well good luck with the snook and I’ll see you "On the Flats".
Gear Check
I have been using the new 8 & 15-pound Power-Pro Lines now for almost six months and I am here to say…I am a believer. The 8-pound is just like thread (has a dia. of one-pound test monofilament) and throws a 2/0 circle hook with a medium size shrimp a country mile. The long casts mean the less chance of spooking bonefish and permit while on the flats. The 15-pound test is a great tool for getting those snook out of a mangrove shoreline. The 15-pound has a dia. of four-pound test monofilament and can spool over 300 yards on a Shimano Stradic 4000 reel. This is a great advantage for tarpon fishing and some of the offshore species.
August Report 2003
Well August is here again, and again we look forward to September first for the snook season to open. The flats are loaded with this fiery villain sitting poised to strike at a properly presented bait. One of my favorites is the High Roller/Rip Roller in the 3.25" size and in the colors of either Florida Special or the new Green Back. Other top water baits like the new Rapala Skitter Walk in the mullet pattern has worked very well. Capt. Rick Murphy gave me a couple of these baits after the ICAST Show to see what I thought, and I like them.
Don’t forget the plastics. My MadMan Baits have been doing the trick in this warm water as well. Rigged Texas Style using a 1/16th oz. bullet weight for casting distance really helps, it also allows the head of the bait to fall naturally. This has been the formula for success catching at least two or three snook before the heat of the day slows down the bite and makes the fish hide out in the deeper edges or cuts of Flamingo.
The early part of the day has been the best for the bonefishing. Being on the water at sunrise is a necessity due to the cooler water temperatures. This is the toughest time for me to tag a bonefish with this hot water. I have been on the University of Miami Bonefish Research program for almost four years now and have gotten a lot of information from the research they are performing. If you have fished with me you will notice I don’t tag all of the fish we catch, as is my standard practice. I will only tag a bone that has been landed in the best of shape to lessen the impact on the fish and ensure it’s survival. I will take a lot of time reviving every fish caught to ensure the fish has had a chance to recover from the fight before releasing him. I hope you all practice the same care when releasing one of our precocious bonefish.
When flyfishing during these calm and quiet days on the flats remember to step down to a lighter weight rod for a softer presentation of the fly to the fish. An eight or nine weight rod is preferred during those windy days, but most of the summer I throw a seven to the bonefish. On occasion, I will use a six weight on a school of smaller fish like we often see on the outside of the bay along Elliot key and up to the Ragged keys and south to Garden Cove. These schools of fish are smaller than the Arsnicker fish and can easily be managed with a lighter rod. Did I mention it’s a lot more fun on a lighter rod as well! Just keep your angles opposite the fish’s direction and apply the pressure from the first two feet of the rod, rather than the tip, to reduce a long, drawn out fight.
The captain has gone off the deep end … that’s right I am venturing out into the deep blue. We have had a great time catching dolphin and king’s summer, and yes I bring my nine weight flyrod with me all of the time. I have gone to the some of the area’s most accomplished offshore anglers for direction and guidance for the fine art of fishing the blue water, and it has paid off. Along with a couple of new sponsors like Accurate Fishing Products and Garmin Electronics, an offshore rookie like me can consistently catch quality fish. The new reels from Accurate I have used are unbelievable. The Boss 197 and 270 are the smaller sizes Accurate makes, but not small in performance. These reels have twin drag systems and nine total ball bearings for a smooth, fast retrieve. Machined out Billet 6061-T6 aluminum, they are made to last a lifetime. Check out my web site for a link or go to www.accuratefishing.com for more info. Better yet, contact Jose Fonseca the owner of The Complete Angler at 305-665-2771, he has the whole line for your inspection.
Gear Check
There are some new hard baits I have been throwing since the ICAST Show. The Strike Pro Lure Company has given me a few of their new shallow diving and surface baits for testing. I will be giving you a full report in the very next issue.
July Report 2003
Has June been a month of nasty weather here in South Florida, or is it just me? Where are the calm days and the beautiful mornings I have been waiting for? The afternoon storms have been building much to early making a short day out on the water.
The water is getting to its warmest temperatures of the summer driving the bonefish to feed early in the morning and in deeper than normal waters during the rest of the day. Target the early morning low stages of the tides for tailing fish. The second week of June we found eaters in good numbers on the inside of the Bay, but only early and with the tide at the low incoming stages. I like to fish a lot of clousers during this time of year in light yellow and tan patterns. Remember that you also need to step down in your rod selection for a softer presentation during the quiet times of the morning. A 7 wt. fast action rod like a G.Loomis GLX with a full floating line is my choice for a long quiet cast. The GLX matched up with the new Old Florida Super Arbor, makes for a lightweight and comfortable rig to handle for a day on the water. A lot of my anglers are used to the lighter weight sticks that are used for trout fishing, and when I hand them a 9 wt. they think it’s a broomstick. Just make sure that your reel has a sufficient amount of backing to fight our Biscayne Bay Bones.
To keep your fly line, leader and fly from splashing down on the surface of the water as you make your last forward cast, aim five feet above the water and the leader will straighten out, then float down to the surface. This will decrease the slap and also allow your leader to turn over properly. Keep your rod at the five-foot level until your leader turns then lower your rod tip to the water to gather any slack, and you’ll find you will be in a better position for a strike, much quicker.
The permit are still getting more numerous in the Bay and on the outside flats. These guys are the toughest fish to target on fly. Compounding the problem, you also need at least a 20-pound leader to reduce the risk of separation when the fish digs his nose on the bottom to try to get rid of the hook. I will increase my leader length to sometimes over ten feet to keep the larger diameter fly line as far away from the fish as possible. The use of P-line Fluorocarbon Leaders has also increased my hook-up percentage a great deal. The old reliable Merkin Crab and the newer Quan Fly are the best percentage patterns I have used this season. A 9 wt. seems to be the best bet for the wilily permit and I also like a Loomis GLX for this challenge as well. The faster action rods have a much better control over not only the distance but also the placement of the fly. The proper shot, at the right time using the right fly will give you a very good chance of a hook-up to the black eyed permit.
Gear Check
Just a reminder to you all who were asking for the new Folding Weight Nets, they are available now at Don’s Bait & Tackle & A’Ok Bait. There will be another new shop carrying some of my favorite gear. Franco at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop will be stocking all of my favorite colors in High Rollers and MadMan Plastic Baits in his new backcountry selection, so check it out.
New this month I have been using the new MUSTAD Ultra Point Hooks with great success. I really like the strength and sharpness of the new line of hooks. Working the Mad Shad Carolina style has produced quite a few snook out of Flamingo. Going weedless, I can drag the baits thru the grass in as little as six inches of water on the edge of a drop off. This is where the snook are looking to ambush the mullet as they pass. It also works great on the beaches, just throw up on the sand and retrieve into the water for a great natural presentation. Until next month, I’ll see you "On the Flats"
June Report 2003
June fishing should be exactly what we had hoped for in the sense of wind direction, speed and temperatures. The afternoon build-up of thunder storms dictate we start our days early and end them around 2 pm. This is a good practice also due to the South Florida sun baking our anglers to a crisp in the afternoon. Keep in mind you must reapply a generous amount of sunscreen every three hours and keep the flow of liquids into yourself as well as your anglers to keep from becoming toast as we head into the summer months. Reminding my anglers of both of these necessities I feel is a very important part of being a good guide.
As June approaches we will see the water temperatures rising to the point of driving the bonefish off the flats during the middle of the day, although the permit will be showing more and more as the waters warm. Target your bonefishing on those days of an early morning, incoming tide. The influx of cooler water flooding the flats will turn on the bite and give you a better chance of hooking the ghost of the flats.
When flyfishing for bones on the flats, I change flies almost as often as we change flats. I always try to match the bottom color with my selection of flies as I pull onto a flat. The forage food of the bonefish will adapt a color consistent of the bottom color where they live to better camouflage themselves against being the main course of the day. Fluorocarbon leaders are also a must to fool the bonefish, as well as a well-placed cast of your fly or bait. If you can position yourself in the path of the fish and pull your offering straight away, the leader will be in front of the fly and not visible to the fish.
This is the best time to try for the Grand Slam of the flats. To catch a bone, permit and tarpon in the same day is very possible during the three months of summer. Permit being the toughest of the three to get to eat, this is the time of year the greatest numbers of fish gather on our flats. Target them with a 1 ½ " crab on a 2/0 circle hook, at least a 20 pound fluorocarbon leader and hold on for the fight of your life. Have your Captain keep fairly close to help keep the line out of the fan coral and off the bottom for your best chances to keep a fish on.
Tarpon will still be very much present in our waters, and in good numbers now that they have ended the spawning cycle. They will be much more aggressive feeders now since they don’t eat much during the spawn. The cockroach patterns have been very successful in the early parts of the day and as the sun climbs higher in the sky, switch to a chartreuse or white and yellow combination for the best results. I’m hearing more and more that circle hooks are being used rather than the old standard hooks for a better catch percentage. Just fight the urge to strike and set the hook, with the circle hooks all you need do is lift the rod to lodge the hook in the corner of the mouth and in the ensuing fight the hook will be imbedded deep enough to land the fish. Please take the time to revive the fish properly after you land one of these friends of mine to ensure their survival. They are just too valuable to catch only once.
The ICAST Show is again in Las Vegas this year and your captain will be attending, so look for a report in the July issue for the lowdown on this fishing manufacturers convention. All the products for the sport will be there and it will be held July 9th thru the 11th. I am sure I’ll have a few new products to tell you about.
I’ll see you " On the Flats"
Gear Check
Even with the wind being up we have been able to fly fish with the help of the Pro Trim Line Tamer. This stripping bucket takes away almost all of the aggravation when trying to cast in a wind and is a much-needed tool on my bow when there is a 15 or 20-knot wind blowing. We have been using the Old Florida Super Arbor fly reels with Old Florida’s new IM6 Graphite Fly Rods with much the delight of my anglers. These reels are of the highest quality you can find out there on the market period. If you feel that you need to spend more money on a reel ….Buy Two.
May Report 2003
Here we are in the glorious month of May again. Bonefish are schooling all over our Biscayne Bay flats, permit are working on the edges and deeper flats, and the tarpon are heading south for the Keys.
There is no better time to be a fisherman or guide here in South Florida. I find it to be the hardest at these times, when there are boats all over the place, to keep the right distance from my fellow anglers. Other boats are cutting off my fish when I am on a tarpon run or a bonefish flat, people are running all over the flats trying to get from one spot to another. This is when we need to discipline ourselves the most. When you are out there fishing, please try to remember not to run over flats that someone might want to fish, even if the isn’t anyone in sight. Keep your distance from other boats that are in line on a tarpon run. When approaching another boat, try to think of how he or she is fishing, are they drifting a flat? Are they poling down wind for the best visibility? Or they set up on a point waiting for a school of tarpon to cross their path. In any of these scenarios, give way to allow plenty of room. If you can see who it is in the boat, or if it is a Maverick or a Hell’s Bay, YOU’RE TOO CLOSE. I personally will try to give just a little bit more respect to "the other guy" out there this year. Ok, I’ve said my piece.
The Herman Lucerne was another success this year. With a grand total of 52 boats and 120 anglers that caught and released over 254 fish, it was a great weekend. Some of the very best guides we have from Ft. Lauderdale to Islamorada participated in the event this year, some took top trophies and some just enjoyed the format of two day’s fishing for seven species of fish in the waters of Florida Bay.
There are a few anglers that deserve a mention from the tournament this year like Brian Brodrick, the new owner of Hell’s Bay Boatworks. Fishing with our own famous guide and fellow Tournament Committee Member Rob Fordyce, Brian was able to amass 70 points on fly to receive the set of three fly reels donated by Tibor.
I would also like to mention Flip Pallot who so graciously showed up for the Awards Banquet and told us an old story of how he meet Herman Lucerne. Flip was a guide for many years in the keys and was in Hells Bay with an angler when he found himself totally lost. Hearing the sound of an outboard in the distance he headed in that direction and found Herman who led him out. See, everybody gets lost in Hell’s Bay when they first start out. Flip is going to film our tournament this year, fishing with Rob Fordyce in the new Hell’s Bay Poling Skiff. The strategies of how to win will be discussed as well as some great fishing action. The episode will air on "The Walker’s Cay Chronicles" so be sure to tune in. Check out walkerscaychronicles.com for airdates.
The top Team went to two of the best guides in the Keys, Rich Tudor and Tom Rowland. These two team up for Team Maverick/Yamaha to fish in the Professional Redfish Tour and Tom is on the Old Florida Team with me as well. Great job guys.
Victoria Horn fishing with her husband Dennis took the Top Female Angler for the second year in a row, great job!!! Both belong to the South Dade Anglers Fishing Club and have had a friendly competition going on with my wife Julie and myself for three years. This year Julie was only off by a half-inch of the Largest Trout and an inch off the Largest Redfish awards, but had enough points to earn me the Top Guide.
If you haven’t fished this tournament, please check this one out and put it on your calendar for next year. Yes, there is stiff competition, and yes, you have to do really well to win even if you are a pro, but all of the monies raised go the Children’s Services of Homestead Hospital where taking care of sick children is the #1 priority.
I have received a lot of calls about the February article I did on the McLean Folding Weight nets. Well, they are finally here in South Florida. Don’s Bait & Tackle and A’ Ok Bait & Tackle both are as of know stocking these high quality nets. The Yellow Bait House in Key Largo will have them as well soon. Thanks to all of your interest, we all can have one of these great nets.
Be safe on the water and I will see you "On the Flats"
Here are the Final Standing’s for the
2003 Herman Lucerne Memorial.
Overall Winner of the 16’ Hell’s Bay "Whipray" & 40 HP Mercury 4 stroke: Tom Roland & Rich Tudor Points: 167.5
Second Place: David lee, Richard Kernish & Jorge Valverde
Points: 132.5 Second & third was decided by time (Time 11:15 a.m.)
Third Place: Al Alesi, Dave Pratt & Eric Herstedt
Points: 132.5 (Time 1:40 p.m.)
Top Guide: Captain Dave Sutton
Fly Fish Division: Bryan Brodrick Points: 70
Largest Fish Division:
Trophy plus a $300 Award went to all of these winners.
Largest Tarpon Angler Eddie Carman
Size 31 inches
Largest Snook Angler Tony Horsley
Size 35.5 inches
Largest Redfish Angler Stephen Denkert
Size 30.5 inches
Largest Trout Angler David Lange
Size 22.5 inches
Largest Snapper Angler Mark Gillman
Size 19 inches
Largest Bonefish Angler Jim Trice
Size 31.5 inches
Largest Bass Angler David Pratt
Size 19 inches
Largest Black Drum Angler Jorge Valverde
Size 25 inches
Top Anglers Division:
Top Male Angler Alan Cockerham Points: 116
Second Place Male Angler Stephen Denkert Points: 111.5
Top Female Angler Victoria Horn Points: 98.5
Second Place Female Angler Linda Robinson Points: 91.5
Third Place Female Angler Julie Sutton Points: 90
Top Junior Angler Sebastian Juncadella Points: 40
Second Place Junior Angler: Benjamin Evans Points: 17
April Report 2003
Miami’s Biscayne Bay has been full of tailing bonefish and should continue to get even better as the month of April approaches. Water temperatures are still in the mid-seventies and the winds have been maintaining a somewhat easterly direction making for perfect conditions on the bay.
Tagging nine bonefish in two days is a testament to the availability of working fish. The bones have been active all over the bay with the warmer temperatures, from the west bay all around the Chicken Key area south to the north end of Key Largo. Large schools of fish are up on the flats tailing and feeding. I have been on many nice schools of fish over on the east side of the bay from Caesar’s Creek south to Angelfish & Broad Creeks as well. With the Tarpon and Snook hanging around the same cuts we have had good luck soaking mullet and pilchards as well. Look in the inside creek mouths, and channel entrances during an incoming tide for the better shots.
Don’t forget the Herman Lucerne Memorial this April 12th & 13th. The Captains Meeting will be at Harris field in Homestead if you want to sign up late and fish for a $30K Hells Bay boat. Lots of other prizes as well, plus all of the proceeds will go to the Children’s Services at Homestead Hospital, so how can you go wrong!
Winter Tarpon is in full swing from the bridges of Miami all the way over the Florida Bay and Flamingo. Whitewater Bay has been a frequent haunt for my anglers while throwing HighRollers and Bagley’s mullet baits for the Kings. Landing two fish a day has been the average, although you need to jump another five to seven fish to keep the odds this good. Casting poppers and shallow divers is a lot of fun for these giants, especially when they take a swing at your lure five feet away from the boat. Remember, natural colors in clean water and bright colors in dirty water has been the measure of success on my boat this season.
Throwing a fly has only been done by the die-hard anglers who can stand up to blind casting in a fifteen-knot wind for a chance of jumping a fish up to 170 pounds. As tuff as it may sound, this has been the tactics that has landed eight fish over a hundred pounds in the last month.
Snook and redfish are all over the backcountry of Flamingo as well as the outside flats into Florida Bay. Cobia and tripletail are on the crab pot buoys and the Spanish macks are in full force. If you are planning a guided trip here in So. Florida there isn’t a better time to go.
Gear Check;
Old Florida rods and reels have been passing out a real whooping to some very large Tarpon. I use a 12 wt. IM6 rod with a #8 Super Arbor that holds 300 yards of 30 pound backing and is just as tough as nails. The drag performs perfectly and as smooth as the day I took it out of the box, but this reel has taken over twenty five Tarpon this season alone without missing a beat
March Report 2003
With the cold fronts finally over, now all we have to put up with is this winds of March. It seems they have started early this year and will hopefully end early. Water temperatures are reaching the almost perfect 72-76 degrees on our waters of Flamingo and Biscayne Bay, making the start of spring official.
I want to say thank-you to all of those who came out on the High Roller/ Mad Man Weekend just to say hello. Many of those who stopped by came just to see the new colors of the MadMan baits and the High Rollers I am always writing about, and maybe get a hat or Tee shirt. We had a great turnout at Don’s Bait & Tackle in the morning and also at A O’K Bait later on that Saturday.
I also worked the Bass Pro Shop Spring Classic. This was my first of these working the isles of a huge retail shop and I found it challenging. Eight hours flew by as I was fielding all types of question from how to tie a hook on to the most advanced way to work jerk bait for redfish. There were so many guides, vendors and professional fisherman at the show giving seminars and working the isles I was amazed. If you missed it this year you have to make this event next year just for the chance to talk to all of the Pro’s and get the skinny on your favorite baits as well as the newest ones out and of course there was the sales!!!
When Jon Hass came into town with the almost perfect water temperatures we were excited about the possibilities. I told him the bonefish were going to be pretty hot and I was right.
Fishing the inside of Biscayne Bay we were on fish the whole day boating three and having a huge fish (12 to 13 pounds) rub us off at the end of a two hundred yard run. These older fish have the smarts to avoid capture using there power and speed running off the flat and then turning and putting a belly in the line. At that distance the angle of your line allows them to swim through the grass and create friction on the line. I use Power-Pro 10 pound test for the bones and every once and awhile will have a fish rub us off. The strength of the braid has greatly decreased the number of times this happens.
Fishing my old friend Tony and his friend Doug out in Flamingo we scored eight redfish using MadMan’s Mad Shad up on the flats sightfishing. This type of fishing was new to both anglers and I wanted to give them a real good dose of the hunt that is involved. The weather was perfect for the stalking in eight to ten inches of water we would be in and the wind was blowing at only ten knots. After landing several fish that were sighted, cast to, and hooked, Doug turned to me and said, "this is something I will be doing a lot of Dave".
When we landed the first double hookup we went directly to the livewell for the two we were going to keep and set up this photo. Yes, we released two of these fish in great shape after we took this shot. The stalk and hunting of fish is something I enjoy very much and have inducted two more anglers into this club.
Gear Check
This month I have been trying out the new 8 & 15-pound Power-Pro Lines. The 8-pound is just like thread (has a dia. of one-pound test monofilament) and throws a bait keeper hook and a MadMan Mad Shad a country mile. The longer the casts, the longer your baits will be in the strike zone. Hence a 20-foot longer cast means a 20% better strike zone time. The 15-pound test is a great tool for those tournaments that restrict my anglers to 16-pound test. Before I had to use 10-pound and on tarpon it makes it tough. The 15-pound has a dia. of four-pound test monofilament and can spool over 300 yards on a Shimano Stradic 4000 reel. This is a great advantage for tarpon due to the casting advantage and the size of gear. Throwing a Stradic 6000-size outfit in Whitewater Bay for six hours is a chore; this is what I needed when I used monofilament lines.
February Report 2003
Did someone move the Equator and neglected to let me know? As the cold fronts continue with the winds coming from all directions, even sometimes in the same day, I find myself waiting for the right times to take my anglers out to fish. Of course some are here on vacation and are restricted as to when they can go, but my local anglers are on stand-by for some of the best fishing they have ever seen. Watch the weather patterns develop, and you will see a cold front diminish to a two or three day warming trend until the next front will approach. These are the golden days for the flats fisherman. The warming days just before a new cold front moves in will be the most active days for the fish. As the barometer drops the bite will be on, all you have to do is be there.
I have had a chance to get one of my best anglers out there during this type of scenario and the day we had was astounding. How about a 37 redfish day, all but 10 fish were sighted and cast to with the result being a fish to the boat. Over and over that day we were amazed to see the flaring of a redfish’s gills as he inhaled our MadMan Mad Shad baits. We motored to Porpoise point and poled through Garfield and Rankin bites for nine hours and never going more than 30 minutes without seeing fish. But beware the shallow water in these areas, my Maverick Mirage HPX-V was dragging butt for most of the day in six inches of water with myself and one angler aboard. It was a day we will not forget for the rest of our lives.

All of our 37 redfish except three were in the slot.
Two were too big and one was two small.
Redfish are a perfect example; these fish are very hardy and can withstand very cold-water temperatures as seen at the Titusville Professional Redfish Tour this past January 11th & 12th. Water temps were down in the low fifties on the Wednesday before the tournament and the fish were not active at all. Thursday we saw a five-degree water temperature rise throughout the day and the bite was on big-time. Just this small rise in temperature will trigger the bite. Holding the fifth spot in a 124-boat field on our first day (Friday) of competition we hoped the patterns we were fishing would hold for Saturday.

Professional Redfish Tour, Titusville Event, Day one
Capt. Dave Sutton & Capt. Dave Baskin w/ 13.71 pounds-Fifth Place
Our final day saw the wind come around 180 degrees and the air temperatures dip ten degrees. This was the end of the patterns we found, on the flats we were fishing. We had to scramble, taking the info we had on a west wind we tried to target the same patterns on an east wind on the lee-side flats. With the colder water temps and the windy conditions we could only muster one fish for a 26th place finish. We missed the last money spot (25th place) by .03 pounds. Considering we finished over 98 other very good fishing teams, of which over 40 teams didn’t weigh a single fish, we were happy, not satisfied, but happy. You can follow each event at www.redfishtour.com Look at some of the pictures of the combatants and you will think we are fishing in Alaska!!!!
Snook season is open as of February 1st. I hope that the last cold spell has not been as severe as all has said. The Snook-kill could be tragic to all of us who love to target them, this just means we have to practice Catch & Release to the max. I will not kill a snook this season if the cold water has had the effect that we think it will. If we just give them a chance they will be as plentiful as the redfish are.
Gear Check
This month I have been trying out the new 8 & 15-pound Power-Pro Lines. The 8-pound is just like thread (has a dia. of one-pound test monofilament) and throws a bait keeper hook and a MadMan Mad Shad a country mile. The longer the casts, the longer your baits will be in the strike zone. Hence a 20-foot longer cast means a 20% better strike zone time. The 15-pound test is a great tool for those tournaments that restrict my anglers to 16-pound test. Before I had to use 10-pound and on tarpon it makes it tough. The 15-pound has a dia. of four-pound test monofilament and can spool over 300 yards on a Shimano Stradic 4000 reel. This is a great advantage for tarpon due to the casting advantage and the size of gear. Throwing a Stradic 6000-size outfit in Whitewater Bay for six hours is a chore; this is what I needed when I used monofilament lines.
January Report 2003
Windy, windy, windy. Why won’t the weather services just tell the truth. I have read 5 to 10 knot winds over and over but when I get on the water it is a whole different story. I guess they mean the aggregate of 5 to 10 knots, give or take 5 to 10!
Here we are in 2003 and the January forecast is looking about the same. Cold fronts with a strong to moderate wind make for an interesting day on the water. Don’t call off a day’s fishing because of a 15 to 20 knot wind. Just remember it is just as hard for the bonefish to see you, as it is to see him. This is an advantage to the angler.

This is a 13 + pound Bonefish caught in 3 to 5 feet of water with a 20-knot wind blowing. It can be done if you know what to look for.
Last month we spoke about water temperatures and the effect it has on the bonefish feeding patterns. I have been seeing water temps in the lower sixties and even down into the upper fifties. These temperatures make bonefishing very difficult, but not impossible. Have you ever heard of the term "deep water bonefishing"? When the surface water temperatures are in the upper fifties to the lower sixties bonefish will tend to stay in water three to six feet deep due to the more stable temperatures. Spotting fish at this depth is a real challenge. I concentrate on looking for mud’s put up by feeding fish, as well as ray mud’s. As a bonefish feeds he will have his head down in the grass routing out shrimp and small crabs creating small puff muds. These muds will appear as very little spot muds and will dissipate very fast in any current situation. As a fish moves into the current he will put up a few of these puffs and let you know his direction and how many fish by the amount of puffs.
Snook season is closed till the end of January and for a very good reason. The gathering of the largest fish I have ever seen over the past two weeks has been happening here in Biscayne Bay as well as in Flamingo waters. The winter migration of snook finds the masses moving into the creek mouths, under the mangrove overhangs and into the backcountry of Flamingo. These fish are looking for more stable water temperatures just like the bonefish.

Just look at me in this shot, I have two shirts and a polar fleece vest on trying to keep warm. I guess I am getting acclimated after fourteen years here in So. Florida. The air temp this day was 62 degrees and I was freezing. But the snook were feeding in the backcountry of Flamingo. We landed six snook this day with the largest being over twenty pounds. Just slow down you’re presentations just like you would if you were bass fishing in cold water and you will find the fish. They gotta-eat man!!!!!
The Ranger/Mercury Professional Redfish Tour will kick off its 2003 season this Jan. 11th & 12th in Titusville. Capt. Dave Baskin and myself make up the "High Rollers Professional Redfish Tour Pro-Team" We will be fishing all six events this year being sponsored by some our very best companies, High-Rollers, MadMan Lures, TIB Bank, Mercury, Power-Pro Lines, Cape-Fear Rods, G.Loomis, Shimano, Power-Pole & Stiffy Push Poles. All of the very best will be there looking for that first place victory. This year all of the six events will be two-day competitions for a first prize of a Ranger Boat with Mercury Outboard, Ranger Trail Trailer and a Minn-Kota Trolling Motor, a value of $30,000.00 plus $5000.00 cash. The field is limited to 100 teams (there are waiting lists for all six events) and there will be prize money given all the way down to 25th spot. Look for updates in next month’s column for the results.
Gear Check.
Even with the wind being up we have been able to fly fish with the help of the Pro Trim Line Tamer. This stripping bucket takes away almost all of the aggravation when trying to cast in a wind and is a much-needed tool on my bow when there is a 15 or 20-knot wind blowing. We have been using the Old Florida Super Arbor fly reels with Old Florida’s new IM6 Graphite Fly Rods with much the delight of my anglers. These outfits are of the highest quality you can find out there on the market period. If you feel that you need to spend more money on a rod and reel ….Buy Two. I have just started using the new Crank-Roller from High Roller with very good results as seen in the snook shot above. This bait wags ever so slowly with a slow retrieve and reaches depths of up to six feet. This is the pattern we found to work on big backcountry snook in cool water conditions and I am dying to try it on the Whitewater Bay Tarpon come this February.
Tight lines and quick releases ………….
November Report 2002
October has seen the infiltration of the bonefish returning to the Biscayne Bay area in force. With the water staying warm, an 82-degree average, the bones are feeling fall slowly coming on, and with that warm water and the lack of a strong cold front the permit are staying around as well. I have been seeing schools of LARGE bonefish all over the bay and they have been eating on fly as well as bait.

Fishing the Redfish Tour Event in Sarasota with my alternate angler Larry Maurer, owner of Thermal Concepts of Ft. Lauderdale, we did very well. This was the first time fishing that area and I was amazed how many snook there are in the area, and how eager they were to assault surface baits like a High Roller-Rip Roller. We scored 22 snook during our two day pre-fish and over a hundred trout, of course this is a redfish tournament right !!! Well we saw quite a few reds while we were slaying snook and in the spots we wanted to see them. Come tournament day we were not surprised to find our spots void of redfish that morning. Luckily we found a school of large redfish and had to land fourteen fish to get our two under or at 27 inches for our 9th place finish with 14.58 pounds. Larry also won the raffles first place prize of a Minn-Kota Bow-Mount Trolling Motor. Not bad for his first tournament.

November should see a strong cold front or two and this will drive to jump start the fishing from Biscayne Bay all the way to the Everglades. As the water-cools off from the summers heat, the bait runs start and all of the Flamingo species revitalize as well as the Bay’s bonefish population. Their favorite water temperatures are from 76 to 78 degrees. At 80 to 82 degrees the fish begin to start schooling and the largest fish of the season will be seen as the water cools down to the magic numbers.
Some of our most famous tournaments will be happening this November & December. Please support these tournaments if you possibly can, they are both for a great cause and will give you a chance to rub elbows with the very best anglers & guides we have here in South Florida.

The Mercury Cheeca Redbone Celebrity Classic will be held Nov. 8, 9 & 10 at the famous Cheeca Lodge in Islamorada. Contact Susan Ellis for info. @ 305-664-2002

The Boy Scout Backbone Celebrity Classic will be held Dec. 3rd thru the 5th. At the famous Ocean Reef Club on Key Largo. Contact Jeff Harkavy @ 954-561-6400
Gear Check
The big bone was caught on a simple clouser minnow in tan & white. An eight weight Old Florida rod with a Old Florida SA 5 reel was the rig. I have been using these Old Florida combo’s for a while and have found them to be the very best value on the market. If you want to spend more money on you next fly rod & reel …. Buy TWO. The Redfish Tour gear was my Cape Fear rods in 8 to 15 pound class with the Finn-Nor Mega-Lites in the 4000 size loaded with the NEW 15 pound Power-Pro line. We were throwing mostly Mad-Man Saltwater Baits with a few High Rollers and we even went to the old trusty Johnson’s Gold Spoons. Tight lines & quick releases.
October Report 2002
With all of the hurricanes around the fishing has been tough. Windy conditions make for a tactical approach to fishing the flats of Biscayne Bay, or even Flamingo for that matter. Wind direction is as critical as tides when making an approach to a flat. Keep in mind that bonefish as well as redfish have pretty good hearing and become spooky when in shallow situations. Always shut down long before you hit shallow water on your approach to a perspective flat. I will give at least a two hundred yard cushion when coming off plane in an area that I want to fish. Idling in a hundred yards is ok, but keep in mind the noise you make will put the fish on alert if nothing else. This slow approach also gives you a chance to observe the flat and prepare you anglers for the hunt.
I have seen too many fisherman run too close to a flat and then wonder why there are no fish on it, or why the fish are so spooky when they do see fish. Have you ever approached a flat that has another boat on it and have the person polling start waving his arms? Most of the flatsmen you see on a flat will do a down sun/wind drift. Drifting with the wind and with the sun at his back makes the visibility in front of the boat the best for sight fishing. DO NOT enter a flat downwind of someone who is already on there, you will be cutting off his drift and hence the arm waving. Take up a position up-wind of him and start your drift to one side or the other. This will give him his room and also give you a chance to intercept fish that got by him. Most of the time, if you watch him close, he will point out fish to his angler or even to you as he makes his way down the flat.
Fishing with a long time friend Ron Sprague from the Tampa area on my new Maverick HPX we found fish in Biscayne Bay in places I haven’t been able to fish with
my old twenty footer.

Here is a shot of Ron and his largest bonefish ever at 11.5 pounds. We also got out in Flamingo and caught snook, reds and trout the day before. The fish don’t know a hurricane is close until the barometer starts to fall. Even with the wind blowing as it did there are little tricks to boat handling that help.
Allowing your boat to broach (drifting down wind with the boat sideways to the wind) will slow down the speed of your drift. This helps you to see the fish without running over them and at the slower speeds you can also stop the boat for a shot without making a lot of noise and commotion. My new Mirage HPX allows me to pole up-wind to a tailing bonefish or redfish without making a sound, yes even in a 20 knot blow, this is something new for me and my anglers love it. Having a power-Pole is also a distinct advantage; I can drop the Power-Pole and stop the boat while still having my push pole in my hand to position my bow for the perfect angle for a presentation of a fly or a better angle to present a shrimp or crab to a fish. Little advantages like these make a big difference when the conditions are against you.
Gear Check
My Maverick Mirage HPX is the newest advantage I have against the wary bonefish. I opted for the Vee rather than the Tunnel due to having to cross Biscayne Bay almost every day. The ride it offers is something I can’t tell you about, you have to experience it for yourself to believe. We were throwing High Rollers (Rip-Rollers) at the snook as well as the new Mad Man Saltwater Shrimp with great results with Cape Fear rods in the 6-12 pound class with Power-Pro 10 pound test lines. P-Line Fluorocarbon leaders of 30 pound test were a must due the snook activity in the area blowing up schools of mullet along the drop-off of a flat into the channels.
Tight lines & quick releases.
September Report 2002
It’s Snookin time again. Snook opens September 1st. and there will be a few anglers out there on the flats all over Florida. With the surface water temperatures still in the mid eighties, expect to find the majority of snook up on the flats feeding on those huge schools of mullet in Flamingo all the way through Florida Bay. The most activity I have been seeing is early in the morning when the flats are coolest and also during a incoming tide. The incoming tidal flow brings cooler water from the deeper cuts to the flats and stimulates the bite. This is not only evident in Flamingo but also in Biscayne Bay. As the cooler water comes in with the tides the bonefish are more comfortable and begin to tail and feed.A morning incoming tide was the factor to these bones caught by Larry & Lauren Maurer of Ft. Lauderdale. We saw fish as the incoming tide rose and on the high to falling tides it was over. The surface water temperature went from 82.3 to 88.9 in three hours.

Our first fish was this cute little 3-pound bone. One of the smallest fish I have seen in my 14 years fishing these waters. Then we got right on track and landed these two beauties at 8.5 & 9.5 pounds.

We then promptly got run off the flats by one of our afternoon thunderstorms that were right at about 3PM, right on time for this time of year!!!
Last Aug. 17th I participated in my first Ranger/Mercury Redfish Tour Event held at Rowell’s Marina on Key Largo. I was fishing with my old friend and fellow Captain, Dave Baskin. Pre-fishing on Thursday we caught a dozen nice redfish and eight snook. Fishing with High Rollers on the surface we had a few other teams scoff as we chugged and buzzed our lures along, but we were catching reds, so we were happy. The fish even cooperated on tournament day with Capt. Baskin scoring a nice 5.77-pound fish. As for yours truly, I had the money fish on twice but just couldn’t get the job done. What we needed was a net with a twelve-foot handle!

The permit are still here in the Bay strong as this 12 pounder proves. We found him on the outside of Sands Cut tailing up on the surface with an outgoing tide. Look fir these fish in the current edges as the tide washes out any shrimp or crabs that can’t hold on. Permit predominately feed on swimming crabs for the most part and will seen up at the surface with their tail and dorsal fins showing. This makes for a great target to shoot at. Just remember the huge black eyes of a permit and make your cast at least eight feet away and up current of the fish. Believe me they will see it, and if they are hungry you will be in for the fight of your life.
Gear Check
The rods we were using was the Cape Fear rods in a 6 to 12 pound class with
Finn-nor 3000 reels loaded with 10 pound test Power-Pro. When using Power-Pro I will always use a P-Line Fluorocarbon Leader approximately eighteen inches long. I use a Palomar knot to my leader from the braid as not to slip under pressure. For the redfish I will always use at least a thirty-pound leader, you might just be in the area of a hungry snook. During the Ranger/Mercury Redfish Tour we used the Rip-Roller and the Original HighRoller in the colors of red & white, Florida Special and Bone. The bones were caught on Owner Circle hooks in a 2/0 size with whole live shrimp.
August Report 2002
Summer is almost gone with the dog days of August here. The fishing has been very good this season in Biscayne Bay. Permit have been overrunning the flats inside and outside of the bay with some very large fish being caught. Targeting permit on spin is a real treat; I start off at the bait shop. Rather than getting five-dozen shrimp and a couple of crabs like I do most of the rest of the year, I order two-dozen crabs and a dozen shrimp. The first dozen of crabs should be the size of a quarter for the large bones and smaller permit, and the second dozen should be the size of a silver dollar. The larger crabs will give you longer casts for the tailing fish and the fish over fifteen pounds will eat them up like M&M’s.
I will have two anglers set up with two different size crabs for most of the day. This gives me the option of throwing at a large fish from a distance or a school of smaller fish up close. Chuck Cash and his fishing buddy Tracy found out that even a smaller permit would take the larger crab. Below is the evidence, a double hook-up on permit is a very exciting event. They were only eight pounds apiece, but what a hoot.

Both Chuck & Tracy caught larger fish that day. Tracy with his eighteen pounder wearing the Gator hat, and Chuck found this fourteen-pound fish with a small crab and a great cast. These guys were very happy anglers that day. What made this day even better was when the school of bonefish came through; Chuck made the perfect cast and came up with a nice eight-pound fish.
Fishing with Patrick Abrunzo from the Abrunzo Golf Institute in Boca, and his associate Mark "Buck" Cangiano, Director of golf at the Ocean Breeze Golf Club, we were about to have a real good day. The water temperature was 88.5 degrees most of the day until the afternoon rains set in. After the rains blew over and got us soaked we found the water temperature fell to 81 degrees and the bonefish loved it. Within a half hour we started seeing large schools coming up on the flats and tailing away with reckless abandon. As you can see, we took full advantage of the situation.

The first fish caught was Buck’s first bone at 8.5 pounds on a small crab. After the photo we pushed back into the feeding frenzy and attempted the unlikely "double hook-up" maneuver. With a little coaching and a five gallon bucket of patience, we scored this double bone with Pats fish at 9.5 pounds on the left and Buck on the right with a 9 pound fish. A double is a rare event due to the wariness of the bonefish. To have two fish take a bait at the same time, from the same school and fight them to photo has only happened to me five times as a guide fishing over ten years. But when the conditions are just right and the anglers follow my instructions you can have a great photo and a great story to tell of a four-bone day.
Gear Check
The gear we were using for those two days "On the Flats" with Capt. Dave was the Cape Fear ADV140-70S sticks. These rods are seven-foot, medium action rods made for 6-14 pound test lines, matched with the Finn-Nor Mega-Lite 3000 reel filled with 10-pound test Power-Pro Braid line. The Owner 1/0 & 2/0 circle hooks worked perfectly with all of the hooks lodged firmly in the corner of the mouth textbook style. The mono leader I will always run from the braid to the hook was 36 inches of P-Line Fluorocarbon leader material in 15-pound test. The lighter the leader the better for the big eyed permit, but when you get into the fish 25 pounds plus and with the combination of large sea fans in the area I will go to a 20 pound Power-Pro rig with 36" of 20 pound leader to increase the chances of a photo finish.
Tight lines & quick releases.
July Report 2002
The rainy season has come in like a lion with almost constant showers on our flats. The beginning of June saw a monsoon of bad weather keeping our water temperature in the upper seventies to the lower eighties. This has been good for the tarpon run and the bonefish are enjoying the cooler water as well. The permit has been showing up in fairly good numbers with the majority o them on our outside flats from Stiltsville south to Garden Cove.
The tarpon run has slowed as of late with the barometer rising and falling like it was on a rollercoaster. With the southern run just about over we should start to see the northern run start as the fish return from the Keys and go north for the summer. This year I have seen the smaller, sparsely tied flies produce a better bite than last year. The Sparky is a fly I have been getting at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop, and have had the most consistent luck with. This is tied on a 2/0 hook with a tail of craft fur vertically striped Borski Style, and just a light palmer of hackle and ice chenille for a collar. Colors have been all naturals, tan & olive, tan & green and tan & brown. Here is proof with the Capt. and a nice hundred pounder.

If permit is your targeted species for the summer like most of us flatsmen, get ready, for the game is afoot. Contrary to popular belief, the permit will eat a well-placed shrimp almost as eagerly as a crab. While bonefishing the outside flats of Elliot Key we have had shots at permit without having the time to change baits from shrimp to a crab. The ensuing casts with shrimp have produced a very good hook-up ratio. The distance to lead a permit is greater than the bonefish due to their fantastic eyesight. On moving fish, I tell my anglers to stay six to eight foot in front of them and just like tarpon, directly in there path. If you are stripping your fly or live bait for that matter, dead away from your target it is almost impossible for the fish to see your leader, this is a big advantage. It also imitates the natural action of live bait fleeing the approaching danger. I tell a lot of anglers we don’t have "attack shrimp" here in South Florida, when they overcast the fish and draw the bait back towards him. This will almost always have an end result of a huge swirl and a head wake blasting off the flat.
The early morning and late evening snook bite is on in the bay with some very large fish being taken all along the bridges of the north bay, out to Star Island. I have been throwing the High Roller, Rip Roller & chrome Rattle Traps for my spinning anglers, while on fly the larger the better. A bulky white or full flashabou fly has been working on fish up to twenty pounds. Fish the structure along the lighted docks and seawalls for the best action, but hang on.
I’m sure you have seen Blair Wiggins from Addictive Fishing using the Cape Fear rods and Fin-Nor reels filled with Power-Pro line up to thirty pound test on his show, well this is the type of fishing that demands that type of tackle. Strong powerful rods with low stretch lines are the combination that is needed to land most of these fish in the pilings and posts that make up the structure the snook inhabit. The sensitivity of Power-Pro gives you a better hook set and the low stretch allows you to drag them out of a sure cut off around a barnacle encrusted piling.
Tight lines & quick releases…
June Report 2002
June is "Grand Slam Month"
June is the best time to slam on the flats. The Tarpon are all over the inside and outside flats, Permit are here in great numbers and the bonefish are starting to school in their summer patterns. Now is the best time to go for the big three and receive the coveted award from the IGFA. All you have to do is record your catches on film and have the paperwork from IGFA to apply for the certificate that is a beautiful addition to anyone’s trophy wall. I will be doing another episode of Addictive Fishing this June, and will let you know when the airtime will be as soon as I know. Wouldn’t be cool if we could slam on the show? Hopefully the winds of May will not follow me into June.
I want to talk a minute about light lining for big fish. This seams to be the craze of late to catch a huge fish on the lightest line possible, well this has its drawbacks. I have caught tarpon on a G.Loomis seven-foot rod made for 8-15 pound test and a Shimano Stella 4000 with 12-pound test P-Line CX Premium and the fight that followed lasted up to two hours. This is a tremendous strain on the fish. Without taking the fish out of the water for a photo, it still took a half hour to revive the fish enough to have a safe release. From know on I will only target large tarpon with a minimum of 15 pound test. I think this is best for the fish as well as the angler. I think it is a win-win situation going to a heavier line. The fish has a better chance for survival, the angler has more control of the fish during the fight, and the line doesn’t end up with as much twist after the fight.
When it comes to bonefishing the same is true. Last week we caught an 11-pound bone on eight-pound P-Line and fought the fish for twenty minutes before landing. Again, without taking the fish out of the water for photos, we tried to revive the fish for almost an hour before it died. This broke my heart. I contacted Mike Larkin from the University of Miami Bonefish Research Project to have the fish examined and hopefully not have this great quarry’s life lost in vain. I felt by using a lighter line we would have a better chance for hook-ups on the weary bonefish but in the twelve years I have been guiding, this is the first bone I have killed. That same day upon returning home I re-spooled all of my bonefishing rods with ten-pound line. Using the P-Line is a major advantage over other lines due to the fluorocarbon coating and it’s ability to conceal itself in the water.
With the winds of May hopefully behind us we look forward to those quiet, sun filled morning’s on our flats here in Biscayne Bay, bonefish up & tailing on the low-incoming tides, permit in schools on the outside creek points looking for crabs and tarpon daisy chaining down the coastal flats. There are a lot of smaller resident tarpon throughout the creeks and channels of our bay as well, just waiting for a well placed shrimp from one of my anglers to shoot skyward and show his stuff.
I hope you all are practicing catch & release whenever you can to help stop the government from imposing NO-Fish Zones in our Biscayne Bay. Please send in your opinion to the National Park Service concerning the unwarranted proposed restrictions. I am of the opinion no-fish zones should be a last resort to a problem, not a first step, and feel they are NOT ACCEPTABLE. Please make your opinion known to possibly sway the parks sediment. You can pick up a copy of the questioner from Dalton’s Marine in Homestead, they have incurred the cost of having copies made to distribute to the public.
One of the way’s that would help stop our depleting fish stocks would be enforcement of the laws, limits and slot sizes already in effect. The Park Service has a system in place to monitor the catches of anglers in the Everglades, why not Biscayne Bay? I personally have seen redfish carcasses floating by the cleaning table at Homestead Bayfront Park and at Black Point Marina at least 33" long. WHY? No law enforcement! Every day I see fishermen at Bayfront Park over by the cannon taking 5, 6, and 7" snapper and putting them in their buckets, I see mutton snapper carcasses floating by the docks way under the 16" slot limit from the cleaning table. There must be a step-up in presence of law enforcement personal at our docks and cleaning tables. It seams to me this would stop a lot of fish kill all by itself without telling me I can’t go fishing in MY Biscayne Bay….. or, I can’t buy shrimp because the shrimpers cannot fish the Bay anymore. Please let your voice be heard, remember, many of our people have died to keep the freedom to do just that.
Tight lines & quick releases…
Here is a big bone from Biscayne Bay… almost 13 pounds.
Caught on live shrimp.
May Report 2002
Well May is here and June, just around the corner. I have said to many of my anglers and at seminars in the past, "the fish don’t go by the calendars." The tarpon don’t know that it is May, and it is time to start the run south, the snook haven’t seen the news to know that it is time to come out of the backcountry and infiltrate the flats.
The Poinciana in my yard is starting to bloom at least three to four weeks early this year due to the warmer air temps and afternoon rains mother nature has been serving up. The tree, just like the habitual fish are responding to the conditions, as should we as anglers.
Outside and inside Biscayne Bay the permit are in full force, the tarpon are running in large schools on their way south for the Keys party and the bonefish are schooling up as if it were late May.
Brian Dolne and his dad Chris came down from Indiana to catch their first bonefish on our Biscayne Bay flats in April, and what a first fish it was for the 13 year old. Weighting in at 11+ pounds, Brian bested his dad’s catch by over three pounds, but Chris didn’t mind having an eight pounder as his first saying "as long as there are many more to come". A quarter size crab convinced the big bone to eat on the Cutter Bank Flat on an outgoing tide and made the a great day of Barracuda, sharks and bonefish.

The Upper Keys are seeing their fair share of the big three as well. Fishing Islamorada every chance I can get, we have seen Permit on the inside of the Downtown Flat, all the way into Rabbit Key Basin along with the bonefish and tarpon. Just west of The World Wide Sportsman docks we found laid up tarpon along the edges of the flats just waiting for the boat traffic to slow down later in the day to feed on our carefully placed flies. Many of the Keys guides will fish into the sunset hours to have the advantage of reduced pressure and increased feeding of almost all the species we hunt.
The designer of the Grasshopper Lure that I have told you about in previous print has done it again. Dave Kaiser has designed yet another jig type of bait that I am testing out this month of May and will fill you in as soon as we can refine the lure. "It was a lure I used to fish with thirty years ago" say’s Dave, "I kept thinking if I could only change it this, and make this longer, it would work much better". Well, he did, and we are catching trout and redfish with regularity. Add a few more colors, and I think we have got it. I will fill you in next month.
Tight lines & quick releases.
April Report 2002
April is coming and May soon to follow. This is the best time to be a Captain here in South Florida. The Tarpon will soon be off Biscayne Bay, (they are already on the outside of Flamingo) the bones are warming up on the flats, the permit have already shown up on our flats and the list goes on & on.
The Upper Key’s are coming alive with snook as well as permit as of late. I have had great success with a new bait called High Rollers with the snook, redfish and trout this spring. I have been using a Rip-Roller, which is surface propeller bait and have been having a ball, try them out. You can get them at Don’s Bait on US 1 in Homestead.
I have been fishing Rabbit Key Basin quite often and have found tarpon up to 170, bones on the flats and permit sunning themselves just like it was summer in two to four feet of water. Check out my web site www.saltwater-flyfisherman.com for the latest pics of the Goliath Grouper (formally known as the Jewfish) caught on ten-pound test P-Line CX premium, and convinced out of his hole after a twenty-minute battle by Steve Batten. Steve is the Head Coach for the girl’s softball team and Assistant Head Coach of the football team at Felix Varela High School. Great job Steve. Of course we released the fish after making sure it was in good shape.
There is still a ban on taking the Goliath Grouper in Florida waters, but I have been catching far too many of them to feel a need for a zero bag limit. The same story is true of the gulf fishery. Fishing the sand holes, potholes and wreaks of the gulf I have experienced the abundant numbers of Goliath’s. While snapper and cobia fishing we have found that a Goliath has moved in to the wreak and will not allow us to boat more than four to five fish without making our snappers live-bait. Once the grouper has moved out of his hole, you cannot bring up another fish without him jumping all over it. I think we should have a minimum size and a daily bag limit of at least one of these fish to help ease the pressure a 200-pound fish like this can make on a small fishing spot.
This past weeks I have fished with Kevin Jenning’s from Dallas Texas for his first bonefish at 12+ pounds, caught in Biscayne Bay on live shrimp, Stephen DiBiagio from Maryland for his first bonefish and 10+ pounds, Charlie Scandorie from New York for his first out of four that day, redfish on fly in Flamingo at 10 pounds. The real story is the Glen Gallager family. Glen, while coaching a collage baseball team here in South Florida for the Plat-off’s, had a chance to take his family fishing. Glen, his wife Gwen, and his two sons, Austin and Cameron, fished with me in Flamingo and his youngest son, Cameron at age 9, caught a 40+ pound Sawfish on ten-pound test line P-Line. I had a shock tippet of 25lb. Seaguar Fluorocarbon on, but only about 12 inches long, and he still got this fish to the boat. Great job Cam!!!
With the weather being warmer than normal for this time of the year, expect to find the spring quarries here and in full regalia sooner than the calendar dictates. The Tarpon will usually be in Flamingo’s Whitewater Bay till the April run to the Keys, but this year the bite has been on & off to say the least. The slightest bit of cold front that comes thru gets them in the eating mood, and then they disappear. Look for the bones to start moving to the south on the outside of Biscayne Bay and the permit showing up on their usual haunts. The bones will also start to form schools with up to 20 fish pushing a big visible head wake to shoot at. Tight lines & quick releases.
March Report 2002
April is coming and May soon to follow. This is the best time to be a Captain here in South Florida. The Tarpon will soon be off Biscayne Bay, (they are already on the outside of Flamingo) the bones are warming up on the flats, the permit have already shown up on our flats and the list goes on & on.
The Upper Key’s are coming alive with snook as well as permit as of late. I have had great success with a new bait called High Rollers with the snook, redfish and trout this spring. I have been using a Rip-Roller, which is surface propeller bait and have been having a ball, try them out. You can get them at Don’s Bait on US 1 in Homestead.
I have been fishing Rabbit Key Basin quite often and have found tarpon up to 170, bones on the flats and permit sunning themselves just like it was summer in two to four feet of water. Check out my web site www.saltwater-flyfisherman.com for the latest pics of the Goliath Grouper (formally known as the Jewfish) caught on ten-pound test P-Line CX premium, and convinced out of his hole after a twenty-minute battle by Steve Batten. Steve is the Head Coach for the girl’s softball team and Assistant Head Coach of the football team at Felix Varela High School. Great job Steve. Of course we released the fish after making sure it was in good shape.
There is still a ban on taking the Goliath Grouper in Florida waters, but I have been catching far too many of them to feel a need for a zero bag limit. The same story is true of the gulf fishery. Fishing the sand holes, potholes and wreaks of the gulf I have experienced the abundant numbers of Goliath’s. While snapper and cobia fishing we have found that a Goliath has moved in to the wreak and will not allow us to boat more than four to five fish without making our snappers live-bait. Once the grouper has moved out of his hole, you cannot bring up another fish without him jumping all over it. I think we should have a minimum size and a daily bag limit of at least one of these fish to help ease the pressure a 200-pound fish like this can make on a small fishing spot.
This past weeks I have fished with Kevin Jenning’s from Dallas Texas for his first bonefish at 12+ pounds, caught in Biscayne Bay on live shrimp, Stephen DiBiagio from Maryland for his first bonefish and 10+ pounds, Charlie Scandorie from New York for his first out of four that day, redfish on fly in Flamingo at 10 pounds. The real story is the Glen Gallager family. Glen, while coaching a collage baseball team here in South Florida for the Plat-off’s, had a chance to take his family fishing. Glen, his wife Gwen, and his two sons, Austin and Cameron, fished with me in Flamingo and his youngest son, Cameron at age 9, caught a 40+ pound Sawfish on ten-pound test line P-Line. I had a shock tippet of 25lb. Seaguar Fluorocarbon on, but only about 12 inches long, and he still got this fish to the boat. Great job Cam!!!
With the weather being warmer than normal for this time of the year, expect to find the spring quarries here and in full regalia sooner than the calendar dictates. The Tarpon will usually be in Flamingo’s Whitewater Bay till the April run to the Keys, but this year the bite has been on & off to say the least. The slightest bit of cold front that comes thru gets them in the eating mood, and then they disappear. Look for the bones to start moving to the south on the outside of Biscayne Bay and the permit showing up on their usual haunts. The bones will also start to form schools with up to 20 fish pushing a big visible head wake to shoot at. Tight lines & quick releases.
February Report 2002
Is this the effects of global warming? Are we seeing a steady rise in temperatures and a warmer, milder winter this year? Down here in South Florida it has been unseasonably warm all winter and the fish are responding. Talking to Capt. Steve Holmes who guides in the St Augustine area I am told the same scenario exists in the north end of Florida as well. I guess it is more a case of trends in the weather patterns rather than global warming, but all I know is the fishing conditions are much better because of it.
Miami’s Biscayne Bay has been full of tailing bonefish and should continue to get even better as the month of March approaches. Water temperatures are still in the mid-seventies and the winds have been maintaining a somewhat easterly direction making for perfect conditions on the bay. Tagging nine bonefish while only fishing for them for five day’s in the past twenty is a testament to the availability of working fish. The bones have been active all over the bay with the warmer temperatures, from the west bay all around the Chicken Key area south to the north end of Key Largo. Large schools of fish are up on the flats tailing and feeding. I have been on many nice schools of fish over on the east side of the bay from Cesar’s Creek south to Angelfish & Broad Creeks as well. With the opening of snook season this February 1st we have targeted linesiders in the bay as well. Look in the creek mouths, canal mouths and channel entrances during an outgoing tide for the bets shots.
Winter Tarpon is in full swing from the bridges of Miami all the way over the Florida Bay and Flamingo. Whitewater Bay has been a frequent haunt for my anglers while throwing HighRollers and Bagley’s mullet baits for the Kings. Landing two fish a day has been the average, although you need to jump another five to seven fish to keep the odds this good. Casting poppers and shallow divers is a lot of fun for these giants, especially when they take a swing at your lure five feet away from the boat. Remember, natural colors in clean water and bright colors in dirty water has been the measure of success on my boat this season. Throwing a fly has only been done by the die-hard anglers who can stand up to blind casting in a fifteen-knot wind for a chance of jumping a fish up to 170 pounds. As tuff as it may sound, this has been the tactics that has landed eight fish over a hundred pounds in the last month.
Snook and redfish are all over the backcountry of Flamingo as well as the outside flats into Florida Bay. Cobia and tripletail are on the crab pot buoys and the Spanish macks are in full force. If you are planning a guided trip here in So. Florida there isn’t a better time to go than now. Tight line & quick releases.
January Report .......
Well the cold fronts have finally come to South Florida. Who would have thought the way December was going we would have such severe temperatures in January. It has been a mixed bag of windy days and cold fronts blowing through from the west and north making the bonefishing very tough. With the sudden drop of five degrees in water temperature the bones retreat to the deeper flats and forage there, rather than suffer the cold water on the shallower flats. It will take two or three days in succession to bring them back to tailing water. Watch the surface temps and get ready to fish.
Young tarpon on the other hand can be found in the same cuts and channels during the cold fronts and a well placed shrimp will produce an eruption on the surface that is almost as good as their larger fellows of spring. These young fish like to school and look for the safest hiding spots from the sharks. Fish the hollows under the mangrove shoreline and keep a sharp eye out for snook as well. Any little creek mouth flow that is out of the normal hustle and bustle of traffic will hold fish as long as the flow is coming out of the creek and into deeper water.
Wayne Hockmeyer from Banjo Minnows came down to fish and we went looking for some juvenile tarpon to test the Banjo and, well the bait works very well. The tarpon and the snook we found hiding in the mangroves responded with vigor to the action of the lure because it suspended like a live mullet. We also got three bones in the two-day venture, no, not on the Banjo. All were caught on live shrimp and found hiding in the deeper cuts and channel drop off’s.
The flyfishing was still worth trying if you use a fly with weighted eyes and allowed it to fall to at least three feet before starting to strip. I like to use clousers and Borski’s Fur Shrimp for this due to the upward bent hook design of the fly and it’s sparse tie to help the sink rate. Colors we use are white and light tan, white and chartreuse and white and yellow. These colors seem to be the best bet for the deep edges of the channel when you see mudding fish.
February will show a few more of these cold fronts and with it the blustery winds of early spring to deal with as well. Try to work a specific flat for bonefish over and over again and you will see that there is a general set of conditions that will bring schools of fish to the flat. Wind direction, tide flow, tide time of day and of course the position of the moon. All of these factors dictate whether you will see a few tailers or a few schools of tailers. But most importantly, be patient and enjoy the hunt, even if the score is lopsided. This is called fishing and even the very best guides will return to the dock at times with a final score of bonefish 8 & anglers nothing, every once and a while.
December Report
Well, we are still waiting for our first major cold front and we are already in December. Water temperatures are still very warm for this time of year and the bonefish are still in there fall mode. We have been seeing schools upwards of twenty fish and feeding up a storm on the outside of Key Largo all the way down to Airport Flats.
The "Bear Bones" fly has done it again. This is my own pattern tied in polar bear fur and it has been responsible for a three fish day, on fly. This polar bear fur is really working with not only the bones but the redfish and snook as well. I have tied a few whistlers and deceivers using the polar and Flamingo just isn’t the same. Stop in at Biscayne Bay Fly Shop and take a look at this fur.
The Boy Scout Backbone was held December 7 & 8th in Ocean Reef for its second year and went off without a hitch. Some of our very best guides and anglers were present for the contest and were treated to some challenging weather conditions. Rain and some heavy winds made for some tuff fishing conditions. I fished with the Gator Leasing Group and had a great time with one of the owners of Gator Leasing, John Hamil and his partner from Kerry’s Bromeliads, Kerry Herndon on my boat. Despite the fact I had two good anglers and fish all around the boat for two days, we just couldn’t get the job done. Capt. Rick Murphy and his team of the famous Stu Apte and a very good female angler Susan Grant took the top team honors and fishing in Whitewater Bay for both days paid off. "Finding the edge of the sweet water was the key with the conditions the way they were", said TV host Capt. Rick, " We had the whole place to ourselves for the first day and most of the second, and it really paid off."
Scout Boats and Yamaha Outboards were the major sponsors of the event and with the ambiance of the Ocean Reef Club; it was a class act from start to finish. If you are looking for a tournament to fish and have your entry dollars go to a good cause, this tournament is just the ticket. There were fishing trips auctioned off at the awards banquet for some of the hottest destinations around the world and some fantastic artwork, all donated to benefit the Boy Scouts of South Florida. My congratulations to the tournament committee for creating another well orchestrated event.
Fishing with Chris Dolne of Indianapolis Indiana this second week of December we took a monster barracuda at thirty-seven pounds fishing in Angelfish Creek with a silver spoon tipped with a slice of mullet. What a fight for a fish not welcomed as a game fish by most, but at fifty inches long this was all of a battle lasting for over a half hour.
January promises to be a great month for fishing if we hold in this weather pattern. The bay will be full of bones still in the skinny water and the outside flats will still have the chance of Permit for the angler who has the patience to fish them.
Happy Holiday’s to all of you and keep up the faith in our great country, keep those flags flying, and of course practice catch and release,
and I will see you "On the Flats"
November Report
Fishing Biscayne Bay this November has been an exercise in wind resistance, and it’s just starting. Through the winter till maybe April the wind is your foremost adversary on the flats. Just learn the flats in your area and the different drifts you will need to do during different wind directions, and you will start to see a pattern emerging. The bonefish use the same tricks unless the current is different, then they are governed by the water flow over wind.
A bonefish will always be heading in a up current direction with his nose into the wind, so to speak. So many I have used the term "bird dogging." A bonefish while swimming into the current will sway back and forth to increase the chance of picking up the scent of a food source. Moving right to left as the fish moves up a flat just like a bird dog working into the wind across a field. It really is a beautiful thing to watch.
Tour winter flats only after a couple of cold fronts have passed through the area to see if the fish have been active on them. By winter flats I mean the darker colored grass flats that would warm up quicker than those lighter colored bottoms. If you don’t see fish in the ten to twelve inch water range, move off the flat a little and look for mud’s in the two foot range. Sometimes the lower water temperatures will keep the fish from the tailing water and move them into deeper water due to more stable temperatures.
I have had an advantage over most bone fisherman as of late; I have been using some newly available polar bear fur for my charlies, clowsers and fur shrimp imitations. The results are truly amazing the difference between the craft fur and a natural fur. If inspected very closely you will find the polar fur looks like a glass hair, almost clear, but hollow for floatation. Yes this fur is expensive, but it is truly worth it when you have the results I have been having.
Tournaments
The Boy Scout Backbone will be held in Biscayne Bay this December 6th thru the 9th.at the famous Ocean Reef Club. I will be fishing one of the top men in Gator Leasing, Mr. John Hamil and his fishing partner the owner of Kerry’s Bromeliads, Mr. Kerry Herndon this year. A big thanks to both of these anglers for giving so much to help the Boy Scouts here in the So. Florida area. I will let you know the results of this competition.
The Herman Lucerne Memorial is coming up in April, and the reason I bring it up so soon is the considerable savings for early registration this year. If you pre-register before December 31st. the fee will be only $225, then before April 10th. The fees per angler will be $250, after the April 10th date the entry fees go to $295.00. There have been a few changes in that there will be cash prizes as well as boats, motors and trailers and a chance to win a brand new Chevy Pickup this year sponsored by Blake Chevrolet of Homestead for catching a specially tagged redfish during the contest. All of this is to benefit the Homestead Hospitals Pediatrics wing, that’s right, all for the kids. For more info please contact Monty Lopez, contest director at 305-253-9548.
One last thing while you are surfing the net stop by www.extremeangling.com
This is my newest addition to my list of great sites on the net for fishing information, reports and stories. Just tell them that Capt. Dave sent you ….. Deal?
Tight lines and quick releases and I will see you "On the Flats"
Captain Dave Sutton is an IGFA Certified Captain, Met Registered Captain and a G.Loomis Endorsed Guide fishing Biscayne Bay, The Upper Keys and he is an Everglades National Park Guide. The skipper would like to hear your fishing stories and reports for his website and print. Call him at 305-248-6126 or e-mail him at djsutton@bellsouth.net. His website is www.saltwater-flyfisherman.com
October 20 Tournament Report
The 1st. "A Day on the Bay Tournament was held today with the weather not cooperating at all. The contest was sponsored by the FNGA (Florida Nurserymen & Growers Association) with the proceeds going to the Stan Weyrick Scholarship Fund to help college student who have chosen an agricultural vocation With over 38 anglers and 21 boats entered, we had a few no-shows but the bulk of the entries fished-on. My two anglers started out looking for bones but got rained on heavily so we got on the inside of some little cuts on the west side of Biscayne Bay to stay out of the lightening and found a few small tarpon, some snook and mangrove snappers. This turned out to be the winning edge at the end of the day. We took the Top Female Angler Trophy (Julie Sutton, my wife), Top Junior Angler Trophy ( Andy Rodriguez, a great angler at only 14 years old) and of course the Top Guide Trophy for yours truly Capt. Dave. All of our fish that won there awards were caught on the new Grasshopper Jigs that are made right here in Homestead, Fl. For info on these new jigs call Dave Keiser at 305-245-1744 for local dealers or buy direct. For more info on getting involved in this contest next year (entry only $35 for adults and $10 for juniors and great trophies), please call Tournament Committee Member Capt. Dave Sutton @ 305-248-6126
October Report
The month of October has been a little warmer than most of us fisherpeople would have ordered. The normal cold fronts have not been present to help the bait fish start their migratory drive south, but even without the drop in temperatures the bait has arrived, and in good numbers. There’s plenty of mullet in the bay and the fish are responding well.
The tarpon have re-gathered in the normal haunts to feed on these mullet and we as anglers and guides have been in on the action. Fish the creek mouths on the west side of Biscayne Bay and you will see schools of tarpon, as well as, snook and an occasional school of redfish.
The redfish population in Biscayne Bay has greatly increased in the past two years. The numbers of fish that I have been seeing have been coming close to those of Flamingo. To find reds in the bay you must target them as a species and devote your day to them, just like fishing in Flamingo. Fish the western shores from Cards Town Bridge, north up to the Key Biscayne Causeway. There are plenty of reds as well as trout and snook to be found up against the mangroves and in the mouths of the creeks and channels. Use live finger mullet or pinfish and you will be pleasantly surprised.
I fished the Ladies "Lets go Fishing " Tournament this year and had a great time. Sponsoring the event was Mercury Marine, Mako Marine and Lighthouse Boat Center of Tavernier, to name but a few. Yours truly gave safe boating demonstrations in my Mako Inshore 2000 to two ladies at a time and tried to teach a little about the flats and how to navigate without cutting the grass, the common courtesy of the flats we all would like to see, and some of the rules of the road as well. This was a great event having seminars for spin casting, fly-casting, knot tying, gaffing a fish, how to bait and chum and many others. There are lots of other events coming up in 2002 and you should get involved in. You can get more info at their web site at www.ladiseletsgofishing.com Tell them Capt. Dave sent you.
I will also fish the Inaugural "A Day on the Bay" tournament sponsored by the Florida Nurserymen & Growers Association (FNGA) this is a brand new, low entry, fun tournament with the proceeds going to the Stan Weyrick Scholarship Fund. Entry fees are only $35 for adults and $10 for junior anglers. For more information on this event please contact Katherine Walters at 305-248-1117. Look for the results in the next report.
As for fishing the bay for bones and permit, there are still good schools of permit to be found on the outgoing tides on the outside of all of the cuts to open water. Wherever there is a good current, just pole up, crush up a few blue crabs, and keep your eyes open. The bones will be a day long hunt with the lowered temperatures we have, just bring a five gallon bucket of patience with you and plenty of live shrimp, and you will have a great day.
Hoping all is well, with all of the fuss that is going on around us. Our spirit has never been more banded together than now, and lets keep it that way. We are all Americans! To the people responsible for this mess, all I can say is "You have wakened a sleeping Giant" I’ll see you "On the Flats" Capt. Dave Sutton
Captain Dave Sutton is a Met Registered, IGFA Certified Captain, and a G.Loomis Endorsed Guide fishing Biscayne Bay, The Upper Keys and the Everglades National Park. The skipper would like to hear your fishing stories and reports for his website and print. Call him at 305-248-6126 or e-mail him at djsutton@bellsouth.net. His website is www.saltwater-flyfisherman.com
September 2001
The September rains have cooled off the flats here in Biscayne Bay as well as across the whole state of Florida. I have just spent a day with Blair Wiggins up in the Indian River area catching huge redfish (30+ pounds), and the story is the same up there. As the water temperatures fall off the eighty mark the bonefish begin to feel more comfortable on the flats and will stay in the feeding mode all day. Take this time to watch your tides and record when you have had luck on certain flats. Take note of the wind direction and its speed, check what moon phase was going on during a good day of bonefishing, and you will start to see that there is a pattern to it all. Granted, there are some guides that are just awful lucky. Case in point, did you see my episode of Addictive Fishing?
This is the time of year that all of the major bonefishing tournaments are held from Biscayne Bay, down to the Keys. The permit are still very present on our flats. I have found myself going back to the Epoxy Moe’s in a brown and a tan color on the flyrod. We took three during the second week of September using the Moe after a great summer of luck with them. One thing to remember with an epoxy head is that you must lead your target a little farther due to the weight and lack of bulk, it does give you a noisy landing.
Biscayne National Park has put out a question and answer pamphlet. The reason is to give the people who use the park a chance to give them our opinions and suggestions on how we would manage the resource. It is an open forum to voice your views of what you think needs to be changed, or on the other hand, what should be left alone. Don’t miss this chance to make your suggestions known. I have attended a meeting at the Keys Gate Country Club and got most of my suggestions an actual response. That’s right, from an actual person, a National Park person. As a matter of fact, they asked me for help in spreading the word that this forum exists. There will be another meeting the week of the 24th. In Miami. Look on there web site for the comments that have been made from the public, and a page that you can download and fill out, then send in to be involved in at least some of the decisions that could change the way we use Biscayne Bay. Their web address is www.nps.gov/bisc .
The Flyfishing World Trade Expo in Salt Lake City was a very good show this year. There were many new products available from new and old manufacturers alike. I was very impressed with a new folding net made in New Zealand that I had to bring back with me. Look for an article in next months paper on this folding net and the new Cortland 555 fly line that was shown at the show. There will be a couple of other surprises I will have for you as soon as I get the press releases. These products will be available right here in the South Florida market for you to water test yourselves. Until then I’ll see you “On the Flats”
Captain Dave Sutton is an IGFA Certified Captain, Met Registered Captain and a G.Loomis Endorsed Guide fishing Biscayne Bay, The Upper Keys and he is an Everglades National Park Guide. The skipper would like to hear your fishing stories and reports for his website and print. Call him at 305-248-6126 or e-mail him at djsutton@bellsouth.net. His website is www.saltwater-flyfisherman.com
August 2001
The bonefishing has been just great as you hopefully saw on my episode of Addictive fishing this month. Capt. Blair and your own Capt. Dave caught and released five beautiful bones weighting from six and a half pounds to the “MOGAN” almost ten pounder. All but one was in Biscayne Bay and the Biscayne National Park waters; the exception was on the outside of Elliot Key. Go to the Addictive Fishing web site for streaming video of all the bones.
Capt. Blair Wiggins and the Mogan of the day ... almost ten pounds
We fished with shrimp and circle hooks for the show but also threw a fly rod at some and landed another two fish in the eight pound range on the new crab patterns that Biscayne Bay Fly Shop has. These patterns are very true to life patterns and look extremely good in the water. The balance of the tie is very well done. Pick up a couple and try the tie yourself, just use a little patience when tying the knots in the elastic legs, what a pain.
We also tagged a fish on the show for the University of Miami Research Program. I have been on the program for almost two years now and have gotten a lot of information from the research they are performing. If you noticed I didn’t tag all of the fish we caught, as is my standard practice. I will only tag a bone that has been landed in the best of shape to lessen the impact on the fish. I will take a lot of time reviving every fish caught to ensure the fish has had a chance to recover from the fight before releasing him. I hope you all practice the same care when releasing a one of our precocious bonefish.
During these calm and quiet days on the flats remember to step down to a lighter weight rod for a softer presentation to the fish. My eight-weight rod is my preferred rod during those windy days, but most of the summer I throw a seven to the bonefish. On occasion, I will use a six weight on a school of smaller fish like we often see on the outside of the bay along Elliot key and up to the Ragged keys and south to Garden Cove. These schools of fish are smaller than the Arsnicker fish and can easily be managed with a lighter rod. Did I mention it’s a lot more fun on a lighter rod as well! Just keep your angles opposite the fish’s direction and apply the pressure from the first two feet of the rod, rather than the tip, to reduce a long, drawn out fight.
The captain has gone off the deep end … that’s right I am venturing out into the deep blue. We have had a ball catching dolphin and the king’s are just starting to come in. I have gone to the some of the area’s most accomplished offshore anglers for direction and guidance for the fine art of fishing the blue water, and it has paid off. Along with a couple of new sponsors like Accurate Fishing Products and Garmin Electronics, an offshore rookie like me can consistently catch quality fish. The new reels from Accurate I have used are unbelievable. The Boss 270 and 870 are the smaller size Accurate makes, but not small in performance. These reels have twin drag systems and nine total ball bearings for a smooth, fast retrieve. Machined out Billet 6061-T6 aluminum, they are made to last a lifetime. Check out my web site for further information.

Tournament time is approaching for the angler up for the test. The first one comes to mind is the Redbone Series of contests. Gary & Susan Ellis have been with their daughter Nicole undergoing surgery for a benign tumor next to her spinal cord. Nicole is recovering well and the CF medications are still working well. I would like to wish a fast and complete recovery to Nicole, and hurry back home. September tournaments upcoming are the Mercury S.L.A.M Celebrity tournament held September 7th thru the 9th in Key West, and the Mercury Baybone Celebrity Tournament held September 28th thru the 30th in Key Largo. I will have a listing for the October and November tournaments in next month’s column.
Until then I’ll see you “On the Flats”.
Aug 2001 supplemental

We just finished filming the last episode of Addictive Fishing, airing on the Sunshine Network on Aug 17th at 11:30 AM and on Aug. the 19th at 10 PM due to the football games. The regular Sunday air time for Addictive Fishing is 8:30 PM. Capt. Blair Wiggins and yours truly fished Biscayne Bay for bones up to ten pounds. Watch the show and let me know if I hammed it up to much ..... Capt. Dave
July 2001 ....
Has July been a month of nasty weather here in South Florida, or is it just me? Where are the calm days and the beautiful mornings I have been waiting for? The afternoon storms have been building much to early making a short day out on the water. The Almanac says we should have a better month of August.
The water is at its warmest point of the summer so far driving the bonefish to feed early in the morning and in deeper than normal waters during the rest of the day. Target the early morning low stages of the tides for tailing fish. The second week of July we found eaters in good numbers on the inside of the Bay, but only early and with the tide at the low incoming stages. I like to fish a lot of clousers during this time of year in light yellow and tan patterns. Remember that you also need to step down in your rod selection for a softer presentation during the quiet times of the morning. A 7 wt. fast action rod like a G.Loomis GLX with a full floating line is my choice for a long quiet cast. The GLX matched up with the new Adventure Series Reels by Loomis, makes for a lightweight and comfortable rig to handle for a day on the water. A lot of my anglers are used to the lighter weight sticks that are used for trout fishing, and when I hand them a 9 wt. they think it’s a broomstick. Just make sure that your reel has a sufficient amount of backing to fight our Biscayne Bay Bones.
To keep your fly line, leader and fly from splashing down on the surface of the water as you make your last forward cast, aim five feet above the water and the leader will straighten out, then float down to the surface. This will decrease the slap and also allow your leader to turn over properly. Keep your rod at the five-foot level until your leader turns then lower your rod tip to the water to gather any slack, and you’ll find you will be in a better position for a strike, much quicker.
The permit are still getting more numerous in the Bay and on the outside flats. These guys are the toughest fish to target on fly. Compounding the problem, you also need at least a 15-pound leader to reduce the risk of separation when the fish digs his nose on the bottom to try to get rid of the hook. I will increase my leader length to sometimes over ten feet to keep the larger diameter fly line as far away from the fish as possible. The use of P-line Fluorocarbon Leaders has also increased my hook-up percentage a great deal. The old reliable Merkin Crab and the newer Quan Fly are the best percentage patterns I have used this season. A 9 wt. seems to be the best bet for the wilily permit and I also like a Loomis GLX for this challenge as well. The faster action rods like the GLX and the Trident TL’s by Orvis have a much better control over not only the distance but also the placement of the fly. The proper shot, at the right time using the right fly will give you a very good chance of a hook-up to the black eyed permit.
See you "On the Flats...
June 2001
June fishing has been exactly what we had hoped for in the sense of wind direction, speed and temperatures. The afternoon build-up of thunder storms dictate we start our days early and end them around 2 pm. This is a good practice also due to the South Florida sun backing our anglers to a crisp in the afternoon sun. Keep in mind you must reapply a generous amount of sunscreen every three hours and keep the flow of liquids into yourself as well as your anglers to keep from becoming toast as we head into July. Reminding my anglers of both of these necessities I feel is a very important part of being a good guide.
As July approaches we will see the water temperatures still rising to the point of driving the bonefish off the flats during the middle of the day, although the permit will be showing more and more as the waters warm. Target your bonefishing on those days of an early morning, incoming tide. The influx of cooler water flooding the flats will turn on the bite and give you a better chance of hooking the ghost of the flats.
When flyfishing for bones on the flats, I change flies almost as often as we change flats. I always try to match the bottom color with my selection of flies as I pull onto a flat. The forage food of the bonefish will adapt a color consistent of the bottom color where they live to better camouflage themselves against being the main course of the day. Fluorocarbon leaders are also a must to fool the bonefish, as well as a well-placed cast of your fly or bait. If you can position yourself in the path of the fish and pull your offering straight away, the leader will be in front of the fly and not visible to the fish.
This is the best time to try for the Grand Slam of the flats. To catch a bone, permit and tarpon in the same day is very possible during the three months of summer. Permit being the toughest of the three to get to eat, this is the time of year the greatest numbers of fish gather on our flats. Target them with a 1 ½ “ crab on a 2/0 circle hook, at least a 20 pound fluorocarbon leader and hold on for the fight of your life. Have your boat operator keep fairly close to help keep the line out of the fan coral and ff the bottom for your best chances to keep a fish on.
Tarpon will still be very much present in our waters, and in good numbers now that they have ended the spawning cycle. They will be much more aggressive feeders now since they don’t eat much during the spawn. The cockroach patterns have been very successful in the early parts of the day and as the sun climbs higher in the sky, switch to a chartreuse or white and yellow combination for the best results. I’m hearing more and more that circle hooks are being used rather than the old standard hooks for a better catch percentage. Just fight the urge to strike and set the hook, with the circle hooks all you need do is lift the rod to lodge the hook in the corner of the mouth and in the ensuing fight the hook will be imbedded deep enough to land the fish. Please take the time to revive the fish properly after you land one of these friends of mine to ensure their survival. They are just to valuable to catch only once.
The ICAST Show is in Las Vegas this year and your captain will be attending, so look for a report in the July issue for the lowdown on this fishing manufacturers convention. All the products for the sport will be there and it will be held July 11th thru the 13th. I am sure I’ll have a few new products to tell you about.
Until next month, I’ll see you “ On the Flats”
May 2001
Well the winds have finally calmed down and the bite has drastically improved in the bay. The bonefish have been very present all over the southern bay in large schools, all the way down the Upper Keys. I have seen schools in the twenties out on the inside of the Ragged Keys south down to Garden Cove flats. Inside of Rabbit key Basin has gotten much better as of late as well, with reports of large schools moving on the strong tides. Look for tailers on the incoming tides on the outside of Elliot all along the deep edges waiting for the water to rise up onto the flats, but keep an eye out for permit in the 2 to 3 foot water as the tide rises. Look for this to just get better as the water warms.
Tarpon have been reported moving north along the outside of Key Largo and the shore up to Sands Cut in good numbers and have been eaters on chartreuse early in the day and tans to olive patterns midday. There have been good numbers of tarpon moving on the outer edges of First National Bank south & east all the way down to Springer Bank. Look for rollers and get in front of them and take a shot. The patterns are a closely kept secret between the guides and to ask them for the color is my only hope. The colors I have had luck on are the same as listed above in the Bay, just add a yellow and white in the mix for the midday bite. This will also improve as the water gets warmer.
I have just come back from fishing the famous Boca Grande Pass. I was invited to fish the Sportswriters Invitational Tournament held at Millers Marina. The Tarpon Club is the top outfitter for fishing the pass and they are putting out the word about their new Mega Money Tarpon Tournament to be held on the 7, 8, & 9th of this July. The water temp was a little low but the bite was great. Capt. Dan Haley (941-793-FISH) put us on big fish the first day, but no fish to the scales. The second day I jumped a huge fish with Capt. Tim Garland (941-626-2892) that he estimated to be over 180 pounds. I fought the silver king for almost 14 minutes, just one minute shy to get a tournament release.
The tarpon is just as hard, if not harder in that scenario, to land with 30 boats all in an acre of water fishing over thousands of fish. I first thought I wouldn’t like that kind of fishing, but was I ever wrong. This was the most exciting and exhilarating two days I have spent fishing in a long time. Something totally different you really should experience for yourself, at least once. There season will last through July with the numbers of fish reaching into the tens of thousands all in an area of one to two acres. You will be amazed at how these Captains can handle a 24-foot boat in the kind of traffic we have at rush hour on the Palmetto.
For more information about the $1 mil. Mega Money Tarpon Tournament or to set up a trip to this wonderful tarpon paradise contact Jack Harper of Millers Marine at 813-964-2232 or contact the guides I fished for reservations. Both are on the Mercury teams and have the top names in gear aboard their boats. Look on my website for some pictures of the event and a link to The Tarpon Club website.
3/29/2001 .......Islamorada, and Biscayne Bay report.
Fishing this past week in "Downtown" ( this is a flat that is south of Shell Key and is famous for all the film coverage it has received) we saw small schools of permit numbering up to ten and in the twenty pound range but the wind was blowing out of the west and south up to 30 knots. To say the least we had a tough time getting a strike. Bones were present and we boga gripped a nice 7 1/2 pound fish.
Biscayne Bay was better for the numbers of bones, but not the permit. We had twenty fish a day to shoot at and some small tarpon in the 70 pound class eat live mullet in the channels of Broad and Angelfish Creeks. Weather kept a good catch rate from getting better even having Kevin Shaw from Stiffy Push Poles down for a day of fishing while here for the Shallow Water Fishing Show. There were a few boats out on the edges looking for tarpon running south and they did have a few shots ... but we still need a few more HOT days to really get the move going strong....
3/18/2001....... Fishing this week in Biscayne
We bone fished just about all week this week and had some success. Mark from Dallas had the best day on the outside of Elliot Key with two releases of an 8 1/2 pound fish and nice 9 pound bonefish, while having two others on for the first run until a fan coral got in the way. There were also a few shots at permit, but we made them all of fly and had no takers. Fishing on Wednesday we tagged a nice 10 1/2 pounder on the Arsnicker flats only to have a big fat 11 to 12 pounder snub our fly like I was using last years model and insulting him with it. Several schools of fish are being spotted and it looks like the season is fully underway.
3/11/2001........Fishing Biscayne Bay & The Everglades
Fishing the Swamp this week was tough after the weather front came through leaving the water just like a yoo-hoo. When we found a patch of clear water we hit fish, trout, red's and a couple of small snook was the best we could muster up. Enrique and his dad Enrique fished on Saturday but the water was still nasty so our catch didn't change. In the Bay we found allot of cruising bones on the inside flats of Broad and Cesar's creeks. Tailers were found early in the day and on the incoming tides only, but these fish were eaters and as happy as a clam. I boga gripped three fish over 9 pounds this week and two permit (on live crab) in the high teens.
Captain Dave Sutton is an IGFA Certified, Met Registered Captain and a G.Loomis Endorsed Guide fishing Biscayne Bay, The Upper Keys and he is an Everglades National Park Guide. The skipper would like to hear your fishing stories and reports for his website and print.
Call him at 305-248-6126
or e-mail him at djsutton@bellsouth.net.
Destinations Capt. Dave's Credentials
Photo Gallery Book a Trip w/ Capt. Dave
Fishing Reports Tournament Participation
Different Seasons/Different Fishing My Sponsors
Memberships & Subscriptions Articles & Stories